The Beehive: the official blog of the Massachusetts Historical Society

"The pretty little place was burnt to the ground": The Destruction of Darien, Georgia

 

We feel very badly that you were compelled to take part, through your men, in the destruction of Darien, & fully sympathize in the sentiments you express. I sincerely hope that as Genl Hunter has been relieved, there may be a modification of the policy which caused the perpetration of such a deed, & that you may not be obliged again to participate in anything so repugnant to you.

 

This excerpt comes from a letter written by Francis G. Shaw to his son Robert Gould Shaw on 23 June 1863, part of the Shaw-Minturn family papers at the MHS. Twelve days earlier, the 54th Massachusetts Infantry, the African-American regiment Robert commanded, had participated with other troops in a raid on the town of Darien in southeast Georgia.

Unfortunately, our collection doesn’t include Robert’s original letter, but Francis was probably replying to the one Robert wrote to his wife Annie the day after the raid, which she sent on to his parents. Robert’s letter to Annie has been printed in Blue-Eyed Child of Fortune (1992) and other publications.

According to his account, when Union troops arrived at Darien, they found the place all but deserted. James Montgomery, colonel of the 2nd South Carolina Infantry (another black regiment) and post commander, had the furniture, livestock, and other movable property confiscated, then smiled “a sweet smile” at Shaw and said, “I shall burn this town.” Shaw explained:

I told him, “I did not want the responsibility of it,” and he was only too happy to take it all on his shoulders; so the pretty little place was burnt to the ground, and not a shed remains standing; Montgomery firing the last buildings with his own hand. One of my companies assisted in it, because he ordered them out, and I had to obey. You must bear in mind, that not a shot had been fired at us from this place, and that there were evidently very few men left in it. All the inhabitants (principally women and children) had fled on our approach, and were no doubt watching the scene from a distance. […]

The reasons he gave me for destroying Darien were, that the Southerners must be made to feel that this was a real war, and that they were to be swept away by the hand of God, like the Jews of old. In theory it may seem all right to some, but when it comes to being made the instrument of the Lord’s vengeance, I myself don’t like it. Then he says, “We are outlawed, and therefore not bound by the rules of regular warfare”; but that makes it none the less revolting to wreak our vengeance on the innocent and defenceless.

 

Shaw called it a “dirty piece of business” and “as abominable a job as I ever had a share in.” He hated “to degenerate into a plunderer and robber. […] There was not a deed performed, from beginning to end, which required any pluck or courage.” He also feared the raid would damage the reputation of black soldiers. Montgomery’s actions were “barbarous” and gratuitous, he thought, and made him no better than notorious Confederate raider Raphael Semmes. But disobeying orders would have meant a court-martial. Shaw lamented, “after going through the hard campaigning and hard fighting in Virginia, this makes me very much ashamed of myself.”

Luis F. Emilio, another officer of the 54th, wrote about the Darien raid 28 years later in his history of the regiment. Emilio also described the beauty of the town, as well as the looting and destruction carried out by Union troops. But while Shaw’s account was thoughtful and conflicted, Emilio’s was a little more clinical and didn’t address the ethical questions.

Robert Gould Shaw and many other men of the 54th Regiment were killed during the assault on Fort Wagner just a few weeks after the destruction of Darien. Another letter in the Shaw-Minturn collection, written by Rev. Phillips Brooks, summarizes Shaw’s legacy. Brooks wrote to Robert’s mother on 17 Nov. 1892: “Indeed, he belongs to all of us, & to the country, & to history.”

 

permalink | Published: Wednesday, 25 October, 2017, 11:31 AM

Comments 

Oct 26, 2017, 11:06 pm

Nancy Sinton

Having been to Darien a few times, my husband & I were just there yesterday. We had never really walked around the town much before but this time we purposely went to take a photo of a monument next to the city hall which we had only seen at night in the past. It told the story of the devastation & of Robert Gould Shaw. We searched & searched but could not find the monument. There seems to be a different monument in the same spot where the Shaw one used to be. We stopped at the fire department and fellow there said he knew the Shaw monument and was as surprised as us that it was not there and had no idea why it would be gone. We are now back home and don't know who to contact to find out why it is not there. Perhaps you can look into this further.

Oct 27, 2017, 4:27 pm

Susan Martin

What an interesting question! I will definitely see what I can find out.

Nov 1, 2017, 5:23 pm

Susan Martin

Thank you for your comment. I couldn't find the answer to your question on my own, so I contacted the Georgia Historical Society for help. Dr. Stan Deaton put me in touch with Buddy Sullivan, former director of the Sapelo Island National Estuarine Research Reserve and local historian, who tells me:

"There has never been a monument to R.G. Shaw in Darien at any time. There is, however, a GHS historical marker at the Darien City Hall that I prepared about 12 or 13 years ago on behalf of the Lower Altamaha Historical Society. That's the only thing in Darien commemorating Shaw and the burning of Darien. As you know the burning of the town was very controversial at the time and for several generations afterwards so it's hard to imagine a monument to Shaw and the 54th being placed anywhere in town up to at least a century after the event and I know nothing has been done in that regard since then."

The historical marker is located on the front lawn of Darien City Hall.

As as interesting side note, Robert Gould Shaw's mother Sarah Blake Sturgis Shaw, knowing her son's feelings about his part in the destruction, contributed to the rebuilding of the town's Episcopal Church after his death.

Contribute your comments




comment fineprint

Any html tags will be automatically removed.

We will not display or share your email with anyone. We do require the email so we may contact you if there are concerns regarding the content of your comment.

The border of the comment box will appear red if your comment exceeds the size limit of 1500 characters. Comments longer than this will be trimmed.

CAPTCHA Image   new image
  what's this?

The image of letters and numbers is a security measure that helps us prevent spam. Typically only humans can read it correctly; computers and programs designed to scan the web for vulnerable forms cannot. If you cannot read the image, click the "new image" link to generate a different set of characters until you find some more legible to you.

Please enter the characters in the image(no spaces, case does not matter):