Page 1
NOVEMBER
17. SUNDAY
[This entry is a continuation of the last
entry in John Adams diary 35.]
Have you seen says he, a certain Letter written to the
C. de V. wherein
Mr. S.A. is
treated pretty freely. -- Yes says I and several other Papers in which
Mr. J. Adams has been treated so too. I dont know, what you
may of heard in England of
Mr.
S.A. You may have been taught to believe, for what I know, that he eats
little Children. But I assure you he is a Man of Humanity and
Candour as well
[as] Integrity,
and further that he is devoted to the Interest of his Country and I believe
wishes never to be, after a Peace, the Partisan to
France or
England, but to do justice and all the good he can to both. I
thank you for mentioning him for I will make him my orator. What will he say,
when the Question of Amnesty and Compensation to the Tories, comes before the
Senate of
Massachusetts. And when he is informed that
England makes a Point of it and that
France
favours her. He will say here
are two old, sagacious Courts,
eachboth endeavouring to
sow the Seeds of Discord among Us, each endeavouring to keep Us in hot Water,
to keep up continual Broils between an English Party and a french Party, in
hopes of obliging the Independent and patriotic Party, to lean to its Side.
England wishes them here and compensated, not merely to get rid
of them and to save
them selves the Money, but to
plant among Us Instruments of their own, to make divisions among Us and between
Us and
France, to be continually crying down the Religion, the
Government, the Manners of France, and crying up the
Page 2
Language, the Fashions, the Blood &c. of
England.
England also means by insisting on our compensating these worst
of
Ennemies to obtain from Us, a tacit
Acknowledgment of the Right of the War -- an implicit Acknowledgment, that the
Tories have been justifiable or at least excuseable, and that We, only by a
fortunate Coincidence of Events, have carried a wicked Rebellion into a
compleat Revolution.
At the very Time when
Britain professes to desire Peace, Reconciliation, perpetual
Oblivion of all past Unkindnesses, can She wish to send in among Us, a Number
of Persons, whose very Countenances will bring fresh to our Remembrance the
whole History of the Rise, and Progress of the War, and of all its Atrocitys? Can she think it conciliatory, to oblige Us,
to lay Taxes upon those whose Habitations have been consumed, to reward those
who have burn'd them? upon those [illegible] whose Property has
been stolen, to reward the Thieves? upon those whose Relations have been
cruelly destroyed, to compensate the Murtherers?
What can be the design of
France on the other hand, by espousing the Cause of these Men?
Indeed her Motives may be guessed at. She may wish to keep up in our Minds a
Terror of
England, and a fresh Remembrance of all We have suffered.
Page 3
Or She may wish to prevent our Ministers in
Europe from agreeing with the British Ministers,
untill She shall say that She and
Spain are
satisfyed in all
Points.
I entered largely with Mr. Oswald,
into the Consideration of the Influence this Question would have upon the
Councils of the British Cabinet and the Debates in Parliament. The King and the
old Ministry might think their personal Reputations concerned, in supporting
Men who had gone such Lengths, and suffered so much in their Attachment to
them. -- The K. may say I have other dominions abroad,
Canada,
Nova Scotia,
Florida, the
West India Islands, the East Indies,
Ireland. It will be a bad Example to abandon these Men. Others
will loose their Encouragement to adhere to my Government. But the shortest
Answer to this is the best, let the King by a Message recommend it to
Parliament to compensate them.
But how will My Lord Shelburne sustain the shock of
Opposition? When Mr. Fox and Mr. Burke shall
demand a Reason why the Essential Interests of the Nation, are sacrificed to
the unreasonable demands of those very Men, who have done this great Mischief
to the Empire. Should these Orators indulge themselves in Philippicks against
the Refugees, shew their false Representations, their
outragious Cruelties, their innumerable demerits against the Nation, and then
attack the first Lord of the Treasury for continuing to spend the Blood and
Treasure of the Nation for their Sakes.
Page 4
Mr. Vaughan came to me Yesterday, and said that
Mr. Oswald had that morning called upon
Mr. Jay, and told him, if he had known as much the day before
as he had since learned, he would have written to go home. Mr. V. said
Mr. Fitzherbert had received a Letter from Ld.
Townsend, that the Compensation would be insisted on.
Mr. Oswald wanted
Mr.
Jay to go to
England. Thought he could convince the Ministry.
Mr. Jay said he must go, with or without the Knowledge and
Advice of this Court, and in either Case it would give rise to jealousies. He
could not go. Mr. Vaughan said he had determined to go, on
Account of the critical State of his Family, his Wife being probably abed. He
should be glad to converse freely with me, and obtain from me, all the Lights
and arguments against the Tories, even the History of their worst Actions, that
in Case it should be necessary to run them down it might be done or at least
expose them, for their true History was little known in
England. -- I told him that I must be excused. It was a Subject
that I had never been desirous of obtaining Information upon. That I pitied
those People too much to be willing to aggravate their Sorrows and Sufferings,
even of those who had deserved the Worst. It might not be amiss to reprint the
Letters of G.
[Govenor]
Bernard,Hutchinson and Oliver, to
shew the rise. It might not be amiss to read the
History of Wyoming in the Annual Register for 1778 or 9, to
recollect the Prison Ships, and the Churches at
New York, where the Garrisons of Fort
Page 5
Washington
were starved in order to make them
inlist into
Refugee Corps. It might not be amiss to recollect the Burning of Cities, and
The Thefts of Plate, Negroes and Tobacco.
I entered into the same Arguments with him that I had used with Mr. Oswald, to shew that
We could do nothing, Congress nothing. The Time it would take to consult the
States, and the Reasons to believe that all of them would at last decide
against it. I shewed him that it would be a Religious
Question with some, a moral one with others, and a political one with more, an
Economical one with very few. I shewed him the ill
Effect which would be produced upon the American Mind, by this Measure, how
much it would contribute to perpetuate Alienation against
England, and how french Emmissaries might by means of these Men
blow up the flames of Animosity and War. I shewed him
how the Whig Interest and the Opposition might avail themselves of this Subject
in Parliament, and how they might embarrass the Minister.
He went out to
Passy, for a Passport, and in the Evening called upon me again.
Said he found Dr. Franklins Sentiments to be the same
with Mr. Jays and mine, and hoped he should be able
to convince Lord Shelburne. He was pretty confident that
it would work right. -- The Ministry and Nation were not informed upon the
Subject. Ld. Shelburne had told him that no Part of his
office gave him so much Paine as the Levy he held for
these People, and hearing their Stories of their Families and Estates, their
Losses, Sufferings and Distresses. Mr. V. said he had picked up here, a good
deal of Information, about those People, from Mr. Allen and
other Americans.
Page 6
Ridley, Allen and Mason,
dined with me, and in the Evening Capt. Barney came in, and told me that Mr.
Vaughan went off to day at noon. I delivered
to Barney, Mr. Jays long Dispatches,
and the other Letters.
In the Evening the Marquis de la
Fayette came in and told me, he had been to see Mr. de
Fleuri, on the Subject of a Loan. He told him that he must
afford America this Year a Subsidy of 20 millions. Mr. de
Fleuri said
France had already spent 250 millions in the American War, and
that they could not allow any more Money to her. That there was a great deal of
Money in
America. That the Kings Troops had been subsisted and paid
there. That the British Army had been subsisted and paid there,
&c.The Marquis said that little of the
Subsistance or pay of the British had gone into any hands but those of the
Tories within their Lines. I said that more Money went in for their Goods than
came out for Provisions or any Thing. The
Marquis added to Mr. Fleury that Mr. Adams had a Plan for going to the States General, for a
Loan or a Subsidy. Mr. Fleury said he did not want the
Assistance of Mr. Adams to get Money
in Holland, he could have what he would. The
M. said Mr. A. would be glad of it. He
did not want to go, but was willing to take the Trouble, if necessary.
The Marquis said he should dine with the
Queen tomorrow and would give her a hint, to favour Us.
That he should take Leave in a few days and should go in the fleet that was to
sail from
Brest. That he wanted the Advice of Mr. F., Mr. J. and me before
he went, &c. Said there was a Report that Mr. Gerard had
been in
England, and that Mr. de Rayneval was gone. I
told him I saw Mr. Gerard at Mr.
Jays a few Evenings ago.
Page 7
He said he did not believe Mr. Gerard had been. That he had
mentioned it to C. de V. and he did not appear
confused at all, but said Mr. Gerard was here about the Limits
of Alsace.
The Marquis said that he believed, the
Reason why C. de Vergennes said so little about
the Progress of Mr. Fitsherbert with him, was because the
difficulty about Peace was made by the Spaniards and he was afraid of making
the Americans still more angry with
Spain . . . . He knew the American [were ]very
angry with the Spaniards.
NOVEMBER
18 MONDAY.
Returned Mr. Oswalds Visit. He
says Mr. Strachey who sat out the 5 did not reach
London untill the 10 . . . . Couriers
are 3, 4, or 5 days in going according as the Winds are.
We went over the old ground, concerning the Tories. He began to use
Arguments with me to relax. I told him he must not think of that, but must bend
all his Thoughts to convince and perswade his Court
to give it up. That if the Terms now before his Court, were not accepted, the
whole negotiation would be broken off, and this Court would probably be so
angry with Mr. Jay and me, that they would set their
Engines to work upon Congress, get us recalled and some others sent, who would
do exactly as this Court would have them. He said, he thought that very
probable....
In another Part of his Conversation He said We should all have Gold Snuff
Boxes set with Diamonds. You will certainly have the Picture. I told him
no. I had dealt too freely with this Court. I had not
concealed from them any
usefull
Page 8
and
necessary Truth, although it was
disagreable.
Indeed I neither expected nor desired any
favours from
them nor would I accept any. I should not refuse any customary Compliment of
that Sort, but it never had been nor would be offered me.... My fixed Principle
never to be the Tool, of any Man, nor the Partisan of any Nation, would forever
exclude me from the Smiles and
favours of Courts.
In another Part of the Conversation, I said that when I was young and
addicted to reading I had heard about dancing on the Points of metaphisical
Needles. But by mixing in the World, I had found the Points of political
Needles finer and sharper than the metaphisical ones.
I told him the Story of Josiah
Quincys Conversations with Lord Shelburne in
1774, in which he pointed out to him, the Plan of carrying on the War, which
has been pursued this Year, by remaining inactive at Land and cruising upon the
Coast to distress our Trade.
He said he had been contriving an artificial Truce since he found we were
bound by Treaty not to agree to a separate Truce. He had proposed to the
Ministry, to give Orders to their Men of War and Privateers, not to take any
unarmed American Vessells.
I said to him, supposing the armed Neutrality should acknowledge American
Independence, by admitting Mr. Dana who is now at
Petersbourg with a Commission for
that
Page 9
Purpose in his Pocket, to subscribe the Principles of their
marine Treaty? The K. of G.B. could find no fault with
it. He could never hereafter say, it was an Affront or Hostility. He had done
it himself. Would not all
Newtral Vessells have a right to go to America? --
and could not all American Trade be carried on in Neutral Bottoms.
I said to him that
England would always be a Country which would deserve much of
the Attention of
America, independently of all Considerations of Blood, Origin,
Language, Morals &c. Merely as a commercial Country, She would forever
claim the Respect of
America, because a great Part of our Commerce would be with her
provided She came to her Senses and made Peace with Us without any Points in
the Treaty that should ferment in the Minds of the People. If the People should
think themselves unjustly treated, they would never be easy, and they were so
situated as to be able to hurt any Power. The Fisheries,
the Mississippi, the Tories were
points that would rankle. And that Nation that should offend our People in any
of them, would sooner or later feel the Consequences.
Mr. Jay, Mr. Le Couteulx
and Mr. Grand came in. Mr. Grand says there is
a great Fermentation in
England, and that they talk of uniting Lord
North and Mr. Fox in Administration. D. of
Portland to come in and Keppel go out. But this
is wild.
You are afraid says
Mr. Oswald to day of being made the Tools of the Powers of
Europe. -- Indeed I am says I. -- What Powers says he. All of
them says I. It is obvious that all the Powers
Page 10
of
Europe will be continually
maneuvring with Us, to work us into their real or
imaginary
Ballances of Power. They will all wish to
make of Us a Make Weight Candle, when they are weighing out their Pounds.
Indeed it is not
surprizing for We shall very
often
if not always be able to turn the Scale. But I think it ought
to be our Rule not to meddle, and that of all the Powers of
Europe not to desire Us, or perhaps even to permit Us to
interfere, if they can help it.
I beg of you, says he, to get out of your head the Idea that We shall
disturb you. -- What says I do you yourself believe that your Ministers,
Governors and even Nation will not wish to get Us of your Side in any future
War? -- Damn the Governors says he. No. We will take
off their Heads if they do an improper thing towards you.
Thank you for your good Will says I, which I feel to be sincere. But Nations
dont feel as you and I do, and your nation when it gets a little refreshed from
the fatigues of the War, when Men and Money are become plenty and Allies at
hand, will not feel as it does now. We never can be such damned Sots says he as
to think of differing again with you. -- Why says I, in truth I have never been
able to comprehend the Reason why you ever thought of differing with Us.
Page 11
1782
NOVEMBER 19 TUESDAY.
In the Morning Mr. Jay called and took me with him
in his Carriage to Versailles. We waited on the C. de Vergennes and dined with him, in Company with all the
Foreign Ministers, and others to the Number of forty four or five.
Mr. Berkenrode the Dutch Ambassador, told me, that he
thought We should see something very singular in
England. The Conflicts of Parties and contentions for the
Ministry were such, that he did not know where it would end. It was thought
that Lord Shelburne could not support himself without an
Union with Ld. North or Mr. Fox, and
that the Choice of either would determine the Intentions of the Court and
Parliament.
Mr. Brantzen told me, that they had begun the Negotiations
on their Part, but were as yet very far asunder, but hoped they should approach
nearer in a little Time. Both he and Berkenrode asked me how
We advanced? I told him Mr. Oswald was
waiting for a Courier, in answer to his of the 5. which arrived the 10th. I
told them both that We should not be behind hand of them. That if it was once
said that
France,
Spain and
Holland were ready, the British Ministry would not hesitate upon
any Points between Us that remained. They both said they believed We should
find less difficulty to arrange our affairs with England, than
any of the others would.
The Sweedish Minister went to a Gentleman and
asked him to introduce him to Mr. Jay and me which he
did. The Minister told us he had been here since 1766.
The same Ministers are here from
Russia,
Denmark and
Sardinia, whom I knew here, formerly.
Page 12
Mr. Jay made his Compliment to Count
D'Aranda, who invited him to come and see him and dine with
him.
I see, by a long Conversation at Table with the
Baron de Linden, that he has an Inclination to go to
America, Yet he modestly gives Place to Mr.
Vanberckel.
The Marquis de la Fayette took leave of the
King to day in his American Uniform and Sword. He told
me, that the C. de Vergennes told him the day
before that, Mr. de Rayneval was gone to
England again. That he did not think the English so sincere, as
he wished, for a speedy Peace. He wished it himself, but could not see a
Prospect of it, suddenly, &c.
In returning I asked Mr. Jay what he thought of
the K. of Great Britains sending an Ambassador to
Congress. After Mr. Oswalds Commission,
he might do it, and Congress must receive him. -- Jay said do you think with me upon that Point too? If I were
the K. of G.B. I would send a Minister in the highest
Character, he should be Ambassador Extraordinary, and I would accredit him, to
our dear and beloved Friends. And I would instruct that Minister to treat
Congress with as high Respect as any crowned head in
Europe.
But says I, he ought to be well instructed too in other Points -- vizt.
never to hint or to suffer an hint against the Treaties with
France and
Holland, never to admit the Idea of our failing in our public
faith or national Honour -- and farther never to
interfere in our Parties, general or particular, with our internal Policy, or
particular Governments, and to warn our People not to let the French Ministers
do it.
If the Britons should strike with Us, I would agree with you
Page 13
after the terms are signed to advise to the Measure. If I were
the King of G. Britain, I would give Orders to all my
Ambassadors at the Neutral Courts, to announce to those Courts the Independence
of
America, that I had acknowledged it, and given a Commission
under the Great Seal to treat with the Ministers of the
United States of America. That I recommended to these Courts to
follow the Example, and open Negotiations with the said
United States. That I recommended to those
neutralStates to send their
Vessells
freely to and receive
Vessells freely from, all the
Ports of the
United States. I would send the Earl of
Effingham Ambassador to Congress, instructed to assure them that I
would
nodo them my best Offices, to secure to them the
Fisheries, their Extent to
the Missisippi and the Navigation of that River. That I
would
favour all their Negotiations
in Europe, upon their own Plan of making commercial Treaties with
all Nations. That I would interpose my good offices with the Barbary States, to
procure them Mediterranean Passes, &c.
NOV. 20
WEDNESDAY.
Dr. Franklin came in, and We fell into
Conversation. From one Thing to another, We came to
Politicks. I told him, that it seemed uncertain
whether Shelburne could hold his Ground without leaning
Upon Ld. North on one hand or Fox on the other. That if
he joined North, or North &
Co. should come in, they would go upon a contracted System, and would join
People at this Court to deprive Us of
the
Missisippi and the Fisheries
&c. If Fox came in or
joined Shelburne they would go upon a liberal and manly
System, and this was the only Choice they had. No Nation had ever brought
itself into such a Labyrinth
Page 14
perplexed with the demands of
Holland,
Spain,
France and
America. Their Funds were failing and the Money undertaken to be
furnished was not found.
Franklin said, that the Bank
came in Aid, and he learned that large Sums of Scrip were lodged there. -- In
this Situation says I they have no Chance but to set up
America very high -- and if I were King of
G.B. I would take that Tone. I would send the first Duke of the
Kingdom Ambassador to Congress, and would negotiate in their
favour at all the Neutral Courts &c. I would give the
strongest Assurances to Congress of Support in the Fisheries,
the
Missisippi &c. and would
compensate the Tories myself.
I asked what could be the Policy of this Court in wishing to deprive Us of
the Fisheries? and
Missisippi? I could see no
possible Motive for it, but to plant Seeds of Contention for a future War. If
they pursued this Policy they would be as fatally blinded to their true
Interests as ever the English were.
Franklin said, they would be every bit as blind.
That the Fisheries and
Missisippi could not be given up. That nothing
was clearer to him than that the Fisheries were essential to the northern
States, and
the
Missisippi to the Southern
and indeed both to all. I told him that Mr. Gerard had
certainly appeared to
America, to negotiate to these Ends, vizt. to
perswade Congress to give up both. This was the Reason of
his being so unpopular in
America, and this was the Cause of their dislike to
Sam Adams, who had spoken very freely both
to Gerard and his Congress on these heads.
That Marbois appeared now to be pursuing the same
Objects.
Franklin said he had seen his Letter. I said
I was the more
surprized at this, as Mr.
Marbois, on our Passage to America, had often said to
me, that he thought the Fisheries
Page 15
our natural Right and our
essential Interest, and that We ought to maintain it and be supported in it.
Yet that he appeared now to be
maneuvring against
it.
I told him that I always considered their extraordinary Attack upon me, not
as arising from any Offence or any Thing personal, but as an Attack upon the
Fishery. There had been great debates in Congress upon issuing the first
Commission for Peace, and in Setting my Instructions -- that I was instructed
not to make any Treaty of Commerce with
Britain, without an express Clause acknowledging our Right to
the Fishery. This Court knew that this would be, when communicated to the
English, a strong Motive with them to acknowledge our Right, and to take away
this they had directed their Intrigues against me, to get my Commission
annulled, and had succeeded. They hoped also to gain some Advantage in these
Points by associating others with me in the Commission for Peace. But they had
failed in this for
the
Missisippi and Fishery were
now much securer than if I had been alone. That Debates had run very high in
Congress. That Mr. Drayton and
Governieur Morris had openly espoused their Plan
and
A mistake as Mr
J. [Jay] tells me. argued against the Fishery.
That Mr. Laurens and others of the Southern Gentlemen, had been
staunch for them, and contended that as Nurseries of Seamen and Sources of
Trade the Southern States were as much interested as the Northern. That Debates
had run so high that the Eastern States had been obliged to give in their
Ultimatum in Writing and to say they would withdraw, if any more was done, and
that this Point was so tender and important that if not secured it would be the
Cause of a Breach of the Union of the States -- and their
Politicks might for what I knew be so profound as to mean
to lay a foundation for a rupture
Page 16
between the States, when in a few
Years they should think them grown too big. I could see no possible Motive they
had, to wish to negotiate
the
Missisippi into the Hands of
Spain, but this. Knowing the fine Country in the
Neighbourhood, and the rapidity with which it would
fill with Inhabitants, they might force their Way down
the
Missisipi and occasion
another War. They had certainly Sense enough to know too that We could
not
and would not be restrained from the Fishery. That our People
would be constantly pushing for it, and thus plunge themselves into another
War, in which We should stand in need of France.
If the old Ministry in
England should come in again, they would probably join this
Court in attempting to deprive Us. But all would not succeed. We must be firm
and steady, and should do very well. -- Yes he said he believed We should do
very well, and carry the Points.
I told him I could not think that the K. and Council here had formed any
digested Plan against Us upon these Points. I hoped it was only the Speculation
of Individuals.
I told him, that if Fox should know
that Shelburne refused to agree with Us merely because We
would not compensate the Tories, that he would attack the Minister upon this
Ground and pelt him so with Tories as to make him uncomfortable. I thought it
would be very well to give Fox an hint. -- He said he would
write him a Letter upon it. He had sometimes corresponded with him,
and Fox had been in Conversation with him here, before I
arrived.
Page 17
I walked before Dinner to Mr. Jays, and told him,
I thought there was danger, that the old Ministry would come in,
or Shelburne unite with North.
That the King did not love Us, and the old Ministry did not love Us: but they
loved the Refugees, and thought probably their personal Characters concerned to
support them. Rayneval was gone to
England, and I wanted to have him watched to see, if he was ever
in Company with North,
Germain,Stormont,Hillsborough,Sandwich,
Bute or Mansfield. If the wing clipping System
and the Support of the Tories should be suggested by this Court to any of them
it would fall in with their Passions and Opinions, for several of the old
Ministry, had often dropped Expressions in the Debates in Parliament, that it
was the Interest of
England to prevent our Growth to Wealth and Power.
It was very possible, that a Part of the old Ministry might come in,
and Richmond, Keppel,Townsend
and Cambden go out, and in this Case,tho they could not revoke the Acknowledgment of our
Independence, they would certainly go upon the contracted plan of clypping our Wings. In this Case it is true,
England would be finally the Dupe, and it would be the most
malicious Policy possible against her. It is agreed that if the Whigs go out,
and Richmond,
Keppell,Townsend, Cambden
&c. join Fox and Burke in Opposition, there
will be great Probability of a national Commotion and Confusion.
Mr. Jay agreed with me, in all I had said, and
Added that six days would produce the Kings Speech.
Page 18
If that Speech
should inform Parliament that he had issued a Commission to treat with the
United States, and the two Houses should thank him for it, it
would look as if a good Plan was to prevail: but if not, We should then take
Measures to communicate it far, and wide.
and
I told him I thought, in that Case We should aid Opposition as much as We
could, by suggesting Arguments, to those who would transmit them in favour of
America, and in favour of those who had
the most liberal Sentiments towards
America, to convince them that the Wing clipping Plan was
ruinous to
England, and the most generous and noble Part they could Act
towards
America, the only one that could be beneficial to the Nation,
and to enable them to attack a contracted Ministry with every Advantage, that
could be.
I thought it was now a Crisis, in which good Will or Ill will
towards America would be carried very far in
England, a time perhaps when the American Ministers may have
more Weight in turning the Tide of Sentiment, or influencing the Changes of
Administration than they ever had before and perhaps than they would have
again. That I thought it our Duty, Upon this Occasion to say every Thing We could, to the Englishmen here, in order
that just Sentiments might prevail in
England at this Moment, to countenance every Man well disposed,
and to disabuse and undeceive every body.
To drive out of Countenance and into Infamy,
Page 19
every narrow
Thought of cramping, stinting, impoverishing or enfeebling Us. To
shew that it is their only Interest to
shew themselves our Friends, to wear away, if possible, the
Memory of past Unkindnesses. To strike with Us now upon our own Terms,
because
tho We had neither Power nor Inclination to
make Peace, without our Allies, yet the very report that We had got over all
our difficulties would naturally make all
Europe expect Peace, would tend to make
Spain less exorbitant in her demands, and would make
Holland more ardent for Peace, and dispose
France to be more serious in her Importunities
with Spain and
Holland, and even render
France herself easier,
tho I did not
imagine she would be extravagant in her Pretentions. To
shew them the ruinous Tendency of the War if continued
another Year or two. -- Where would
England be if the War continued 2 Years longer? What the State
of her Finances? What her Condition in the
E. and
W. Indies, in
N. America,
Ireland,
Scotland and even in
England? What hopes have they of saving themselves from a civil
War? If our Terms are not now accepted, they will never again have such offers
from
America. They will never have so advantageous a Line -- never
their Debts -- never so much for the Tories, and perhaps a rigorous demand of
Compensation for the Devastations they have committed.
Mr. Jay agreed with me in Sentiment, and indeed they are
the Principles he has uniformly pursued thro the
whole Negotiation before my Arrival. I think they cannot be misunderstood or
disapproved in Congress.
There never was a Blunder in
Politicks more
egregious than will be committed by the present Ministry, if they attempt to
save the
Honour of the old Ministry and of the
Tories.Shelburne may be too weak to combat
Page 20
them: but the true Policy would be to throw all the Odium of the War,
and all the Blame of the Dismemberment of the Empire upon the old Ministers and
the Tories. To run them down, tarnish them with Votes, envey against them in
Speeches and Pamphlets, even strip them of the Pensions and make them both
ridiculous, insignificant and contemptible, in short make them as wretched as
their Crimes deserve. Never think of sending them to
America. But Shelburne is not strong
enough. The old Party with the King at their Head, is too powerful, and popular
yet.
I really pitty these People, as little as they
deserve it. For surely no Men ever deserved worse of Society.
If Fox was in, and had Weight enough, and should take this
decided Part which is consistent enough with the Tenor of his Speeches, which
have been constant Phillippicks against the old Ministry and frequent Sallies
against the Refugees, and should adopt a noble Line of Conduct towards America,
grant her all She asks, do her honnour and promote her
Prosperity, he would disarm the hostile Mind, and soften the resentful heart,
recover much of the Affection of America, much of her Commerce,
and perhaps equal Consideration and Profit and Power from her as ever. She
would have no Governors nor Armies there and no Taxes, but She would have
Profit, Reputation and Power.
Today I received a Letter from my Excellent Friend Mr. Laurens 12 Nov.London in
answer to mine of the 6. agreeing as speedily as possible to join his
Colleagues. "Thank God, I had a Son, who dared to die for his Country!"
Page 21
1782
NOV. 21 THURSDAY.
Paid a Visit to Mr. Brantzen, and then to
the Comte de Linden; spent 2 hours with him.
He says the King of Sweeden has overwhelmed him with his Goodness,
is perpetually writing to his Ministers to compliment and applaud him for the
Part he has acted in refusing to go to
Vienna and for the Reason he gave for it.
Says the Revolution in
Sweeden, was advantageous to
France, in Point of Economy, for
France used to pay very dear, for Partisans, in Pensions.
That Russia too, used to have a Party there and pay Pensions. Now
by means of the Court,
France predominates, more easily.
He said that on Tuesday he prayed the Introductor of Ambassadors to speak to
the Prince de Tingry to put him upon the List to go to
the Comedy, with the King, Queen and Royal Family, in the little Salle de
Spectacle. That the K. and Q. eyed him the whole Evening, and as they came out
the Introductor told the K. that it was the Comte de
Linden, a Man very zealous for the patriotic System. The K. said
Oui, Je scais son Affair.
He says that there is no Man in the Republic who receives any Thing, from any foreign Prince or State. That the Law
is very strict against it, and obliges every Man to take an Oath that he has
not and will not -- and no Man dares. He dont believe that the Duke ever did. It would be a blunder in the
English to offer it, for he is by his Name and Family enoughattached
without it.
He says, that he has followed the Principles which were given him by
his Uncle, Boerslaer [Boetzelaer], who was
high in favour at Court and in great Power thro the Rep [Republic]. That his Age
and Family would be an Objection against his going to
America, but after Affairs shall be a little settled, he expects
that his Friends will ask him what will be agreable to him, but if not, he shall take his Place in
the States General and retire to his Estate in
Zealand.
Page 22
Ridley and Bancroft came in and spent the
Evening. B. says that Mr. Oswald dont
feel very well, that he thinks of going home. That the K. will bring in some of
the old Minsters, &c.
NOV.
22 FRYDAY.
Made a Visit to Dr. Bancroft, and spent an hour or two with
him. Mr. Walpole he says is a Correspondent of Mr.
Fox. I told him I wished I could have two hours Time
with Fox. -- Visited Mr.
Mayo,Livingston, Vaughan,
Rogers and Lady and Mr. Jay.
Mr. Jay says that Oswald received a Courier from
London last Evening. That his Letters were brought in while he
was there. That Oswald read one of them
and said, that "the Tories stick." That Stratchey is coming again, and may be expected
today. Oswald call'd upon him this morning, but
young Franklin was there: so he said nothing, as he would not
speak before him. Jay says We had now to consider,
whether We should state the question in writing to the Comte de Vergennes, and ask his Answer.
I said to him We must be more dry and reserved and short with
himOswald than We had been. He
said We must endeavour to discover, whether they
agree to all the other Points. I asked what he thought of agreeing to some
Compensation to the Tories, if this Court advised to it. He said they would be
very mad if We did. He said that a Tract of Land, with a Pompous Preamble,
would satisfy the English. But he would call upon Oswald this Afternoon, and endeavour to know more, and call upon me in the
Evening.
Page 23
Bancroft said to day,
that Fitsherbert was sensible but conceited, that the
Englishmen who were acquainted with him however said he was reserved about the
Secrets of his Negotiation: But he expressed openly his Feelings,
when Rayneval went over to
England, as it implied or seemed to imply a Want of Confidence
in him. He was displeased . . . .That he had dined with him and Mr. Jay, at Mr.
Oswalds. He said he found that the Englishmen here, were prepared with
their Quibbles, about the Acknowledgment of American Independence. That the
enabling Act did not impower the King, to grant such a Commission. It enabled
him to make Peace with the Colonies, and to treat and conclude with any Discription of Men, but not expressly to acknowledge
them independent States. So that it might be cast upon the Crown or Ministry as
an illegal Act. Ld. Cambden had given his Opinion that
the Act did not authorize the K. to acknowledge the Independence
of America.
To this it may be answered that the King or Crown cannot go back. That an
Act of Parliament only can annul it. The K. would make himself ridiculous in
the Eyes of all Men, Souvereigns especially, if
he should consent to such an Act. That a Vote of either House of Parliament,
declaring the Commission illegal and null, would never pass. It would break off
all Negotiations,allarm
America and raise a Rebellion in
England.
Page 24
But the Truth is, the Crown of
England is absolute in War and Peace. There is not even a
fundamental Law, as there is, in
France, that the King can not allienate the domains of the
Crown. On the contrary by the British Constitution, the King has Power to cede
and Alienate Parts and indeed all his Dominions, i.e. there is no
Limitation.
Bancroft said there is an Act of Parliament that the King
shall never alienate Gibraltar. So that Gibraltar cannot be ceded to
Spain without an Act of Parliament.
B. says that Mr. Garnier is in
Burgundy upon his Estate, where he passes the Summers, and comes
only to
Paris in the Winter.
B. said if the K. in his Speech should not announce Mr. Oswalds Commission, you Gentlemen
Commissioners would do well to take some measures for the Publication of it,
in England and abroad.
I said I wondered, that Mr. Fox had not sent over some
Friend here, during the Conferences, to pick up what he could of Intelligence.
But upon Recollection, I said his Friends,
Richmond,Keppell, Townsend,
Cambden &c. were in the Council and Cabinet, and therefore
no doubt informed him, of all Intelligence, and let him into all the Secret of
Affairs.
[This entry continues in John Adams diary 37.]