probably intends a further criticism of Lafayette, the head of the
French chapter of the Society of the Cincinnati. The new military order had earned
immediate disapproval of the Adamses, of John Jay and Thomas Jefferson, and even of
Lafayette's ally Franklin, as well as that of many other Americans in France. Lafayette,
sensitive to their anti-aristocratic criticism, labored to explain the Society to
critics, while urging George Washington to seek the alteration of the Society's rules
eliminate the provision for hereditary membership. Washington supported this change,
hostility to the order, strongest in New England and among civilian servants of America
Europe, soon subsided. But
's remarks here and her concern, immediately below,
that Col. Humphreys and Col. Smith were “Knights of Cincinnatus,” demonstrate that
hostility to the order did not die out quickly.
probably learned of Col.
Smith's membership in the Cincinnati in late April. See
to Elbridge Gerry, 28
, Adams Papers
, 11 Feb.
, and note 9
, above; and Louis
Gottschalk, Lafayette Between the American and the French
, 1783–1789, chap. 5.