5 October 1770. MS
not found. Prepared by a committee appointed and reporting 5 October, composed of
John Murray, Joseph Gerrish, JA
, Jedediah Prebble, and Samuel Adams. Murray reported the same day.
In his reply to the House Message of 4 October
(see preceding calendar entry), Hutchinson claimed he was “not at Liberty” to communicate
the order in council of 6 July to which he had referred obliquely in his speech at
the opening of the session. He referred to the “entire Approbation” the Crown had
given to his transfer of the legislature to Cambridge and asserted that he was now
“restrained from removing it to Boston” (Mass., House Jour.
, 1770–1771, p. 87). After Hutchinson's message was read to the House on 5 October,
Murray reported the committee's “unanimous
Opinion, That his Honor's said Message does not afford that Light which the House
requested in their Message to him; and that it appears to them from his Honor's Message,
that he was restrained by Instruction
, from communicating the same to the House in a Parliamentary Manner” (same, p. 88).
was then named to a committee “to prepare an Address and Remonstrance accordingly,”
but the Journal
records no presentation of any such “Address” in that session; indeed, the need for
such a protest was superseded by House action on 9 October (see Editorial Note