. The following essay on the rights of juries, an issue being warmly debated in both
England and America, has every appearance of having been written for a newspaper,
but no printing has been found. Samuel M. Quincy, the editor of Josiah Quincy Jr.'s Reports
, plausibly suggested that at least some passages in it were originally “part of [JA
's] preparation for the argument” in the case of Wright and Gill v.
Mein, which had come before the Suffolk Inferior Court, Jan. 1771, and was appealed
to the next sitting of the Superior Court (Quincy, Reports
, Appendix II, p. 566–567). JA
's extensive notes and authorities for his successful argument in this case—that a
jury can find against the instructions of a court—are in Adams Papers, Microfilms
, Reel 185.