Happy Birthday, John and Abigail Adams!

By Miriam Liebman, Assistant Editor, Adams Papers

Original Image Courtesy of Harvard Art Museums.

Autumn was a celebratory season for John and Abigail Adams. They got married on 25 October 1764, his birthday was 30 October 1735, and her birthday was 22 November 1744. John’s birthday appears throughout the Adams Papers; in his diary entries, letters recalling dinners and parties, and reflections as John got older. Abigail did not reflect as much on her own birthday.

Why did Abigail not write about her birthday? One of John Quincy Adams’s diary entries provides some insight. He wrote, “I remembered very imperfectly my Mother’s birth day, and being desirous of ascertaining it, I rode this afternoon, by the old Penn’s Hill Road to Weymouth, to the House of Mr Nathaniel Blancherd, Town-Clerk. He was not at home, but I found the old Town-Records which were shewn me by his wife. My Mother’s Birth day is there entered 11. Novr. 1744—old Style of course. This makes it 22. November New Style, which in the Episcopal Calendar’s is Saint Cecilia’s day.” Abigail may not have regularly celebrated her birthday since her son did not even know the date.

Writing on his 25th birthday, John admonished himself for not learning and reading more over the previous year, but set the goal to write more in his 26th year. And yet, by his 37th birthday, he exclaimed that his “Season for acquiring Knowledge is past.” He never stopped learning and continued to read and write throughout his life.

While John did not enjoy celebrating his birthday—he was relieved his birthday fell during the congressional recess—many celebrated it on his behalf. Boston area celebrations were quite common, even if John did not attend. At the height of tensions with France in 1799, cousin Cotton Tufts attended a birthday party celebrating John where a toast was given to the envoys to France, “but was not drank by any—to the great Mortification of the Toaster.” For more on John’s appointment of envoys to France and the XYZ Affair, check out the newest book in the Papers of John Adams, volume 23! In 1800, Abigail noted a Boston newspaper’s report of Quincy’s birthday celebrations for John. John Quincy attended a birthday dinner for his father two years later.

Toward the end of his life, family members made sure that John’s birthday did not pass without notice. For his 88th birthday, John planned to have his last sitting for a new portrait. The following year, on his 89th birthday, his grandson Charles Francis Adams intended to come for dinner, but his granddaughter Caroline Amelia Smith DeWindt and relative Harriet Welsh made a small party.

As John got older, the day became harder for him; as his grandson George Washington Adams wrote, “He was born in October, married in October and lost my Grandmother in October.”

The Adams Papers editorial project at the Massachusetts Historical Society gratefully acknowledges the generous support of our sponsors. Major funding of the edition is currently provided by the National Endowment for the Humanities and the Packard Humanities Institute.

The 100th Anniversary of the Oneidas’ An Historical Sketch: archival afterlife and lessons of a ‘usable past’

By Dr. Kevin Tallec Marston, CIES Senior Research Fellow and Visiting Lecturer at De Montfort University’s International Centre for Sport History & Culture (UK)

Winthrop Saltonstall Scudder, An Historical Sketch of the Oneida Football Club of Boston, (1926). Call Number: Ms. S-686b.

So bountiful are the MHS collections that, undoubtedly on any day, the itinerant researcher can request a document whose date will reveal an anniversary. Today, one such document turns a hundred. Entitled An Historical Sketch of the Oneida Football Club, the eleven-page typescript (plus addenda) was donated on October 18th, 1926, by MHS member, doctor, and former player Robert Means Lawrence. Authored by editor Winthrop Saltonstall Scudder, the document recounts the history of their boyhood team’s salient sporting achievements as the first organized football club in America.

But anniversaries, however factually intriguing, are not in themselves significant. A document attains eminence when its memory meets meaning. The Sketch’s import extends beyond having established a definitive story of (yet another) Boston ‘founding first’. To understand the Sketch’s distinction, we must consider the context from which it emerged as well as its surprising historiographical afterlife as an artifact of a ‘usable past’.

Scudder believed he was writing a definitive a posteriori account. To this end, the memoir cites authorities: football experts Parke H. Davis and Walter Camp. Scudder also built on preserved heritage and club artifacts, some of which found their way into MHS collections. The Sketch builds on a 1906 book (Old Boston Boys and the Games They Played) penned by club member, James D’Wolf Lovett, whose richly annotated copy is among the two editions residing alongside his own papers in the MHS archives. In his Sketch, Scudder recounts how the club members donated their old round ball to the Society for the Preservation of New England Antiquities (Historic New England’s predecessor) as authentic evidence of their claims. Honoring the past also meant looking forward. So younger generations would emulate the ideals of sportsmanship so central to American education’s Muscular Christian ethos, Scudder’s band commemorated the 60th anniversary of their 1863 championship in the form of a bronze tablet for Noble & Greenough school accompanied by Parisian-minted medals endowed as student awards—copies of which were also entrusted to MHS.1 Finally, as Scudder explains in the Sketch, the surviving members commissioned a monument on Boston Common to honor the Oneidas as founders of American football.

Noble and Greenough School (Dedham, Mass.) Medals. James D’Wolf Lovett medal, 1926. Call Number: Medals, personal Lovett 01.

Soon began the afterlife of Scudder’s Sketch which saw facsimiles donated widely across Boston’s institutions, six of the eight Ivies, the Library of Congress, and further afield to Oxford University and even the national libraries of Ireland and France. The Oneida story even became an early example of sports marketing. The MHS collections hold a wonderful 1935 lithograph advertisement for the First National Bank of Boston (Bank of America’s eastern predecessor). Produced for the tenth anniversary of the Oneida monument, the print honors the history of American football from its founding on Boston Common.

From Batten, Barton, Durstine & Osborn Inc., [Collection of advertising broadsides] [graphic], (Boston: the Bank, 1934-1942). Call Number: HG2613.B74 F54 1934 X-Lg

In a way, Scudder’s Sketch was just the continued preservation of collective social memory. Gifted by Means Lawrence a few years after another Oneida’s erstwhile MHS presidency (Henry Cabot Lodge), the Proceedings of the Society record at least three other former footballers among the MHS membership (Bishop William Lawrence, Frederick Cheever Shattuck, and William Sturgis Bigelow).2 The Sketch fits naturally into the broader antiquarian movement that so colored this era.3 Yet the Oneida story is also a captivating case study in the faultlines between memory and myth, heritage and history; exactly the kind of ‘usable past’ that Van Wyck Brooks—no stranger to the MHS collections—imagined just eight years before the donation of Scudder’s Sketch.4

For if the original 1926 typescript rests intimately with MHS, once the Oneidas had departed, their memory was no longer their own. Memory ceases to be private when it is published, disseminated, engraved, and even partly scanned for perpetuity.5 A dozen years after the first advertisement, a new print honored—and forever altered—the club’s legacy. As cracks began to appear in the Oneida testimony, Scudder’s old club was reappropriated into American soccer history. Because of how the Sketch was produced, preserved and then disseminated, it became a ‘usable past’, such that it shaped the national origin story of not one, but two sports.6

Of course, New England is accustomed to forks in the road. Let us then allow this autumn centenary to remind us of the unexpected fertile verges of history…where two codes (of ‘foot ball’) diverged in a yellow wood…

Kevin Tallec Marston

Dr. Tallec Marston is CIES Senior Research Fellow and Visiting Lecturer at De Montfort University’s International Centre for Sport History & Culture (UK). He has taught for twenty years on the FIFA Master, lectures in history at the University of Neuchatel (Switzerland), and serves as current president of the Society for American Soccer History (SASH).

Co-authored with Mike Cronin of Boston College, Inventing the Boston Game: Football, Soccer and the Origins of a National Myth (UMass Amherst) was the honorable mention for the North American Society for Sport History (NASSH) 2025 Book award.

The Diaries of Henrietta Maria Schroeder Stout, Part VII

By Susan Martin, Senior Processing Archivist

This is the seventh part of a series. Read Part I, Part II, Part III, Part IV, Part V, and Part VI to catch up.

I’m excited to be returning to the story of Henrietta “Yetta” Schroeder. So far, I’ve been following the Schroeder family’s 1889 grand tour of Europe, as told in Henrietta’s diaries in the Stout family papers at the MHS. After celebrating her 14th birthday on October 9 in Switzerland, Henrietta, along with her mother and three siblings, continued on to—where else?—gay Paree.

Paris in 1889 must have been an amazing place. The city, home to over two million people, saw an influx of over 32 million visitors that year for the Exposition Universelle. The exposition, held from May 6 to October 31, was a celebration of the 100th anniversary of the French Revolution. Its most famous and enduring symbol is the Eiffel Tower, which at the time it was built was the tallest tower in the world.

The Schroeders had passed through Paris on their way south, but this time, they would stay for longer and do some serious sightseeing. They lodged at 7 Rue Marbeuf in the 8th arrondissement. Henrietta described multiple trips to the Louvre, where she saw the Venus de Milo (“the original one”) and the French crown jewels; Notre-Dame Cathedral (“Oh! those windows! those beautiful windows!”); Saint-Germain-des-Prés (“why the very atmosphere was peace and holiness”); Saint-Germain l’Auxerrois; Palais-Royal; Bois de Boulogne (“I don’t think that the whole thing compares to our Central Park”); and Napoleon’s tomb.

And yes, Henrietta did visit the Eiffel Tower, on November 29, 1889. I’ll let her tell you about it in her own words.

Darling dearest old Confidante,

What do you think I did to day? I went to the top of the Tour Eiffel!! What do you think of that? eh?! Yes I went to the very top. (not on foot, of course, but in the elevator, because it is not allowed to go on foot, I don’t know why –) – One thing there, had the queerest effect you ever heard of – There was a heavy dirty fog off in the west, and we were so high that we could see a beautiful sunset over it off in the distance! Isn’t that queer? Though I don’t know much about engineering, I must say I never saw such a wonderful thing in all my life! Every piece of iron, big, or wee had about a thousand nail heads in it (where they were driven into, goodness knows, and he won’t tell) the elevators were managed just like the funiculaire that I wrote about in Montreux. We had to change at every “Étage,” and oh! I nearly froze.

Drawing, in black ink, of a white girl with long dark hair, wearing a long dress and a hat and carrying a closed umbrella or parasol pointed downward. She is standing looking out of the middle of three windows at an indistinct background. On the wall at left is a small poster with an image of the Eiffel Tower and the text: “Tour Eiffel.” The picture is drawn on the top half of page 137 of an open manuscript volume and surrounded by writing. A handwritten caption under the picture reads: “I, on top of the Eiffel Tower.”
Drawing by Henrietta Schroeder titled “I, on top of the Eiffel Tower,” on a page of her diary, 29 November 1889

The Schroeders had been traveling since June. As much as Henrietta was enjoying the trip, she was homesick and missed her friends. On hearing the news, in September, that her family would be returning home early in 1890, she’d written, “WE ARE GOING HOME NEXT SPRING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My dear, isn’t that delicious?” On November 10, she wrote out a “wish” and stuck it to one of the pages of her diary with wax. The wish was unsealed later, presumably by Henrietta herself. It reads, in part:

I wish with all my heart (God grant it) that when I come home next spring, that Lina Wetherill will love me as much, & a great deal more than she does now, and always will remain my best and dearest friend for ever and ever. Amen.

Loose sheet of paper unfolded and lying over the lower half of an open manuscript volume. Attached to the page of the volume with multiple black wax seals is a sheet of paper with writing on it beginning with: “This is not to be opened…” The loose sheet on top contains writing beginning with: “10th of November A.D. eighteen hundred and eighty nine – I wish with all my heart…” Both pieces of text are in black ink and the same handwriting.
Henrietta Schroeder’s “wish,” 10 November 1889

I hope she got her wish!

Stay tuned for more of Henrietta’s story here at the Beehive.

Come Celebrate Indigenous Peoples’ Day at the MHS!

by Alexandra Moleski (Penobscot/Wolastoqey), MA History Day Program Coordinator

In celebration of Indigenous Peoples’ Day, the MHS and other cultural organizations in Boston’s Back Bay will be Opening Our Doors to offer free programming for the general public. Join us on Monday, October 12 from 12:00 pm to 4:00 pm for a day of discussions and family-friendly activities centering Indigenous histories.

As part of programming, I’ve had the pleasure of curating An Echo Through the Ages: Seven Generation Thinking in the MHS Collections, a special display of Indigenous material culture that is on view through October. Seven Generations is a philosophy that has been foundational to many Indigenous communities and cultures since time immemorial. It emphasizes interconnectedness between past, present, and future. In other words, our actions in the present moment should honor the histories and knowledge of our ancestors and communities going seven generations back, while also preserving and protecting that inherited knowledge and the world we live in for the next seven generations. This mindfulness can take many forms, like the preservation of language and ceremonies, or environmental consciousness and social activism.

Each of the items in the display explores themes of shared knowledge, stewardship, and community across generations. Their stories inspire us to reflect on our own histories: what knowledge and values have been passed down to each of us, and how do we honor them in our daily lives? What do we hope to pass to the coming generations?

One of my favorite items is the large 1835 broadside of the Cherokee syllabary, which was completed by Sequoyah in 1821, after a decade of work assigning unique symbols to every syllable in the Cherokee language.

According to Cherokee oral tradition, Sequoyah’s writing system was inspired by the shapes of worms in the earth and birds in the sky, and he would spend hours writing on tree bark or in dirt.

Written communication between Sequoyah and his daughter Ayoka validated the efficiency of his writing system and the need for it across Cherokee communities. In 1828, just a few years after the syllabary’s creation, the Cherokee Nation published the Cherokee Phoenix, the first Indigenous language newspaper in the U.S. By the 1830s, the Cherokee had a 90% literacy rate. Sequoyah’s syllabary was instrumental in unifying the Cherokee Nation in the face of forced removal and preserving their language for generations to come.

Join us on October 12 to learn more about the rest of the collection items in An Echo Through the Ages and to explore additional programming, including “These Are Our Lands, Forever,” a talk withBrad Lopes, Aquinnah Wôpanâak scholar and Director of Education for the Aquinnah Wampanoag Tribe from 1 pm – 2 pm.

Woliwon!

A Balancing Act

By Sara Georgini, Series Editor, Papers of John Adams

As he crested the midpoint of his presidency, John Adams’ public life exploded in crisis. “My Administration, will not certainly be easy to myself.— It will be happy, however if it is honourable,” he observed to predecessor George Washington on 22 June 1798. Our newest scholarship from the Adams Papers, Volume 23 of the Papers of John Adams, illuminates the host of challenges he faced from March 1798 to June 1799. First and foremost, the second president struggled to make peace with France while accelerating plans for national defense. The bribery fiasco of the XYZ Affair and catastrophic failure of the first mission to France, coupled with privateers’ relentless attacks on American commerce, made that task trickier to accomplish.

A white hardcover book with blue-green oakleaf and acorn seal, Volume 23, sits alongside a bookshelf brimming with previous volumes of the Papers of John Adams

When Adams doubled down on his French policy—despite protest from his cabinet and Congress—support flowed in via hundreds of patriotic addresses from all sixteen states in the union. Adams sat down and answered as many as possible, reveling in a wide-ranging dialogue with his fellow citizens about revolutionary legacies, French missteps, and executive power. “Nothing in the course of my Life, has given me a more exquisite pleasure, than the frank acknowledgments from Various quarters,” Adams wrote to Bristol, Penn., residents on 4 My 1798, adding: “Your Freedom and Independence deserve to be maintained at every hazard—”

His popularity peaked quickly. Adams signed off on the Alien and Sedition Acts in July, a legacy-tarnishing set of laws that eroded individual freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution. Democratic-Republicans pushed back. They leveraged the new legislation to foment rebellion against the Adams administration. “I apeal to your conscience if it is not to intimidate the people and force them to a compliance with the unjust unreasonable unconstitutional laws,” author Margaret Rodgers Irvin Smith railed to Adams on 25 April 1799, continuing: “There is more power put into your hands than ever ought to be comited to any one man.” Meanwhile, mounting trouble with France called for a more robust army and navy. The implementation of a direct tax to cover military costs sparked episodes of dissent and even local fury, such as Fries’ Rebellion.

In Volume 23 we use 408 documents to tell fresh stories from the founding era that illuminate President John Adams’ role at home and in the world. This period represents the high tide of archival treasure in the Adams Family Papers. With that in mind, we worked hard to amplify and contextualize new voices while capturing the complex political tumult of early America. One story that leapt from the manuscripts was Adams’ pursuit of a trade deal with the revolutionary Black republic of St. Domingue (now Haiti). In his dealings with general Toussaint Louverture, Adams labored to reestablish profitable commerce in the Caribbean by creating a carveout for St. Domingue amid the roiling embargoes of the Quasi War. Elsewhere, Adams welcomed diverse commentary from a vast realm of correspondents, including Christopher McPherson, a free Black religious thinker; Abigail Fellows Cunningham, a Charlestown acquaintance; and trusted confidantes like Tristram Dalton, John Jay, and Adriaan François Van der Kemp.

With reelection hopes still hazy on the horizon, the president prepared for war and planned for peace. This chapter of John Adams’ public life reveals a series of tough balancing acts: Extend diplomacy and fund military buildup. Evade foreign influence and encourage free trade. Protect civil liberties and defend national security. The political ground shifted under Adams’ feet as well. Rejecting the notion that he should act as head of the Federalist Party, he strained to sustain principles of constitutional balance. On 29 March 1798, with the Franco-American alliance in tatters, John Adams laid out his executive view of affairs to attorney general Charles Lee, writing: “If any one entertains the Idea that because I am a president of three votes only, I am in the Power of a Party, they shall find that I am no more so, than the Constitution forces upon me.”

The Adams Papers editorial project at the Massachusetts Historical Society gratefully acknowledges support for this volume from the National Endowment for the Humanities, the National Historical Publications and Records Commission, and the Packard Humanities Institute. All letterpress volumes of The Adams Papers are printed by Harvard University Press.

“You Have No Home to Come to”: Rena Struggles Through the London Blitz

By Susan Martin, Senior Processing Archivist

Every once in a while, when I’m processing a collection, I run across a person I just want more people to know about. One of those people is Rena Struggles, whose correspondence is part of the Bullard-Lauriat family papers.

Her full name was, amazingly, Cecerina Victoria Struggles, which I think sounds like someone who attended Hogwarts with Harry Potter. Her family apparently called her “Cissy,” but she preferred Rena. She was born in London on June 9, 1885, one of the many children of James and Ida Berger Struggles. At the age of 20, wanting to make her own way in the world, she traveled across the Atlantic to find work in America. She would spend the next 32 years working as a housekeeper and nanny for different families in Massachusetts, including the Lauriats.

After moving back to the U.K. in the late 1930s, Rena corresponded with the Lauriats, particularly the mother Marian. Rena had quite a poetic way of expressing herself. Here’s a taste of her style (she separated her thoughts on the page with dramatic dashes):

Things and people move so much slower here than in America, there is an outward gentleness with an inward strength – in English things and English men – like the slow streams, yet they are deep and strong.

And when Marian was apparently sorting and discarding some of her late husband’s books, Rena wrote:

I know how you all feel, but we must carry on. – it has ever been thus – from the begining [sic] of time – To be strong – brave – great men have lived through the ages – in those that come after them. I don’t believe it makes us cold and hard – no – it gives us a better understanding of Life – only sometimes we learn too late.

Unfortunately, the Struggles family would be indelibly marked, like so many others in London, by the months-long German bombing campaign known as the Blitz. As early as 1938, Rena’s letters had been peppered with references to air raids, gas masks, evacuations, and barrage balloons. By 1940, Londoners were, she said, “well trained,” even the children. Then, on November 18, she wrote a bleak and heart-breaking letter to Marian:

185 Droop [St., the family home] – is no more. Sat. night it was bombed. mother was killed – my sister taken to hospital I know not where yet my youngest brother – and 7 year old son – and his wife – were buried 4 hours – and taken out I believe alright … I feel too bad to cry or write. the message said don’t come home – you have no home to come to … dont tell Patience.

Color photograph of a pile of documents. On the top of the pile is a letter written in black ink addressed to “Dear Mrs. Lauriat,” from London, England, dated 18 November 1940. Lying to the left of the letter is a card reading “In Loving Memory” with a black border around it and an illustration of flowers.
Letter from Rena Struggles informing Marian Lauriat of the death of Ida Struggles and the destruction of the family home, with mourning card

(Patience was Marian’s youngest child, only 12 years old at the time.)

Ida Struggles was killed instantly, along with a neighbor, Ellen Louise Sutton, who was visiting at the time. Rena’s sister, brother, sister-in-law, and nephew survived with minor physical injuries. Ida was buried at Paddington Cemetery six days later, and Rena described the funeral as “hurried,” with no tolling of the bell to mark “the coming of the soul into God’s acre – owing to war … even the cemetry [sic] had been bombed. – stones lying all which ways.” Months later, Rena still hadn’t “cried over mother – or the home. it was too ghastly – I could not.”

Rena herself lived a very long life. She died on June 23, 1981, just two weeks after her 96th birthday. I found an article in the Brighton (U.K.) Evening Argus, published in 1974, that includes the only picture of her I’ve located. She was bed-bound due to a disability, but still worked making clothing for dolls.

Black and white screenshot of a portion of a newspaper article titled “Top Prize to a Woman Who’s a Real Winner,” with one column of text at the right. To the left of the text is a black and white photograph of three white women, one lying on a hospital bed and the other two standing next to it. All three women smile at the camera, and in the foreground are several dolls.
Detail from an article about Rena Struggles in the Brighton (U.K.) Evening Argus, 16 October 1974

What If?

By Ella Starkman-Hynes, Louis Leonard Tucker Alumni Fellow, PhD Candidate at Yale University 

A strange thought occurred to me on the first day of my research fellowship at the Massachusetts Historical Society: most of the scholars around me are probably looking for evidence of things that happened. I might be the only person looking for evidence of things that didn’t.

My dissertation, “A Different Kind of Mirror: Alternate Histories in Civil War Memory,” examines the role of counterfactuals (also known as alternate histories or what-ifs) in constructing memory of the American Civil War from the late 19th century through the present day. In short, it is a comprehensive survey of Civil War memory, told through all the Civil Wars that never happened.

The challenging part of looking for counterfactuals in the archive is that you never quite know where you’re going to find them. In my first few days at the MHS, I spent a lot of time looking through various family papers waiting for what-ifs that never materialized.

Before too long, however, I began to find the kind of large-scale reimagining of the Civil War and its consequences that I had been seeking. Most excitingly, I began to find patterns of counterfactual thinking that appeared across multiple people’s recollections of the war. I found a fascinating counterfactual in Captain John P. Reynolds’ unpublished Civil War reminiscences. Writing in 1893, Reynolds speculated that Richmond, the capital of the Confederacy, could have been taken in 1862. But, he mused, “the peace that followed would undoubtedly have respected slavery as a condition, and this political cancer … would have recovered from the ‘operation’ to still menace the institutions of a great free republic.”

Excerpt from John P. Reynolds Civil War reminiscences, ca. 1897, Massachusetts Historical Society.

I found a similar counterfactual in the unpublished Civil War recollections of Brigadier General Oliver Edwards. Edwards argued that countless unnecessary deaths occurred because President Lincoln could not find the right person to command the Union Army. And yet, it had to be this way — “the God of Battles would not give us any victory that would end the war until the extinction of slavery was certain to be the result.” This use of counterfactual thinking to comprehend the Civil War’s meaning was exactly the type of thing I had hoped to find in the archive, and I was thrilled to see this mode of thinking in Reynolds’ and Edwards’ reminiscences.

Excerpt from Oliver Edwards, “My Recollections of The Civil War,” Clarence Ransom Edwards papers, Massachusetts Historical Society.

I also found some intriguing counterfactuals in the E.W. Kinsley G.A.R. Post Records, a source base which MHS Reference Librarian Dan Hinchen recommended to me. In a newspaper clipping from 1895, I found a record of a speech given by General Nelson Miles in which he asserts that imaginatively inverting the Civil War’s outcome is the only way to “comprehend the magnitude” of the Civil War’s cause. If the North had lost the war, he asserted, “the world could then have said that after nearly 100 years of experiment under the most favorable circumstances  … republican institutions had been tried and had utterly failed on the Continent of America; despotic government, and with it human slavery, would have been the fate of man for an indefinite period of time.”

Printed photograph of General Nelson A. Miles. Grand Army of the Republic, E. W. Kinsley Post No. 113 (Boston, Mass.) records, Carton 2, Massachusetts Historical Society.

Although historians have been somewhat wary of drawing scholarly conclusions from counterfactuals, this reticence comes at a cost. Gavriel Rosenfeld, a pioneering scholar of counterfactuals, has noted the importance of this genre for memory studies: “Speculative accounts about the past, he writes, “are driven by many of the same psychological forces that determine how the past takes shape in remembrance. Biases, fears and wishes, the desire to avoid guilt, the quest for vindication — these and other related sentiments all influence how people remember how it ‘really’ was.” What-ifs, although unconventional sources, can thus add a great deal to our understanding of how Civil War memory has evolved — or failed to evolve — over the course of the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries.

Works Referenced:

Gavriel Rosenfeld, “Why Do We Ask ‘What If?’ Reflections on the Function of Alternate History.” History and Theory 41, no. 4 (2002): 90–103. http://www.jstor.org/stable/3590670. 93.

“Privacy Was Their Ambition”: John Adams and The Anglo-American Peace Treaty of 1783

By Kevyn Spill, Adams Papers Intern

Detail of Definitive Peace Treaty between the United States and Great Britain.[Treaty of Paris.], 3 September 1783

Hello, my name is Kevyn Spill. I have worked as a remote intern for the Adams Papers at the MHS during the summer. I am currently a rising senior student attending Trinity University in San Antonio, Texas. I had the privilege of transcribing documents for the Papers of John Quincy Adams and researching correspondence for the upcoming Winning Peace select topics webpage, which details John Adams’s role in negotiating Anglo-American peace at the end of the Revolutionary War. In the process of this research, one letter in particular stuck out to me as an interesting reflection of John Adams’s character while he served in politics, that being a letter addressed to his wife Abigail on 27 February 1783.

By this time, John Adams had already written several letters detailing his desire to leave France and return home. He missed his wife, children, and extended family dearly. In other letters, Adams worried about the health and well-being of his brother-in-law Richard Cranch. However, he felt it was his “Destiny” to remain in France and secure peace for his new nation. He understood that he had “come into Life at a critical dangerous time, and to see Prospects before me that I dreaded and wished to avoid but could not, with Honor or a good Conscience.”

With this in mind, Adams referenced both John Dryden and Roman senator Scipio in his understanding of what it means to be a good patriot and servant to his country. Dryden was a popular English poet and playwright who described a patriot as someone who helps their country flourish. Scipio, Adams noted, “served his Country, when it was in need of his Courage and Conduct” but “dismounted from the Saddle, when he found the Beast which bore him began to grow restif and ungovernable.”

Several lines of handwritten text on sepia-toned paper
Detail from John Adams to Abigail Adams, 27 February 1783

Adams believed he had similarly served his nation in its time of need and could now return to more peaceful endeavors. “No Honors, not a Crown—no Profits, not all the Indias, would be the smallest Temptation to me now to go thro’ it again, nor would ever have tempted me to begin it,” he wrote. “I thought it my Duty and that I should be a guilty Wretch if I did not do it.”

While Adams longed to be reunited with his family in Massachusetts, he remained in France and signed the Definitive Anglo-American Peace Treaty on 3 September 1783, thus winning peace for the early republic he had fought so hard to create. “I took my Part according to the Dictates of my Heart and Head,” Adams wrote, “and have gone thro’ it and all its Horrors, and landed the Public safe and glorious in the Harbour of Peace.” 

For more information about the Adamses and their roles in and reflections on securing peace at the end of the Revolutionary War, see the upcoming Winning Peace select topic page.

I am incredibly thankful for the Adams Papers to give me the opportunity to work on both the Winning Peace select topic page and correspondence of John Quincy Adams over the summer. I look forward to using what I learned here in my future studies and career.

New Audiovisual Material at the MHS Digital Archive

By Susan Martin, Senior Processing Archivist

At the beginning of last year, my colleagues Caitlin Walker and Nancy Heywood introduced you to the MHS Digital Archive, our then-brand-new repository of born-digital and reformatted audiovisual material. The archive has grown by leaps and bounds since then. I’d like to plug one particular collection we’ve acquired that includes digital material: the records of Massachusetts Peace Action, or MAPA.

MAPA, a state affiliate of Peace Action, was founded in the 1980s, primarily in response to the proliferation of nuclear weapons. The organization advocates for an end to wars, violence, militarization, and imperialism around the world. Their records, donated to us between 2013 and 2020, fill fourteen record cartons and include meeting minutes, reports, newsletters, correspondence, financial records, newspaper clippings, etc.

The donation also included twelve audiocassettes and eight VHS tapes, dating primarily from the late 1980s and 1990s. This audiovisual material has been reformatted and is now available at the MHS Digital Archive. The easiest way to find it is to follow the blue links from the Massachusetts Peace Action collection guide.

Color screenshot of a blurry video showing four people seated in chairs at the front of a room. Along the right of the screen is a time-stamped transcript.
Screenshot of a video from the Massachusetts Peace Action records

You can listen to a conference call discussing organizing strategies; watch a 1989 forum of  speakers from the Soviet Union (unfortunately the audio’s pretty rough on this one); or virtually “attend” some of MAPA’s conferences featuring speeches by Asoka Bandarage, Noam Chomsky,  Robert Reich, Bernie Sanders, and others. There’s a wealth of information here; for example, I recommend the very interesting remarks of community activist Betty Richardson at a 1993 workshop on the intersection between race and the peace movement.

AI-generated transcripts are available, but I want to emphasize that all the description and metadata work for this material was person-generated. I’m particularly pleased with how well we’ve been able to integrate these digital and digitized items with the organization’s paper records.

When the MHS does not hold copyright to digital material, researchers must be physically present in our Reading Room to view it. But most of Massachusetts Peace Action’s digital material may be enjoyed from the comfort of your own home. So can many other items in the MHS Digital Archive, which we hope you’ll spend some time browsing through.

New Collection Available for Research

By Susan Martin, Senior Processing Archivist

I’m very happy to announce that the Bullard-Lauriat family papers are now available for research at the MHS. I’ve been processing this collection for longer than I care to admit, but it’s definitely been worth it. It’s a fascinating collection documenting the lives of multiple generations of the related Bullard and Lauriat families.

Color screenshot of a webpage titled “Bullard-Lauriat family papers.”
Screenshot of the collection guide to the Bullard-Lauriat family papers at the MHS

If you know any of the Bullards or Lauriats, it’s probably Charles E. Lauriat, Jr. Long-time Bostonians may remember Lauriat’s bookstores, which closed in 1999. Lauriat’s began as Estes & Lauriat, co-founded in 1872 by Charles’s father, and Charles served as president of the company from his father’s death in 1920 to his own in 1937.

Charles is probably best known today for one dramatic incident in his life: he survived the sinking of the Lusitania on May 7, 1915. In fact, he didn’t just survive; he saved the lives of many others, as well. His correspondence from that time describes the events and their aftermath. I particularly enjoyed it when Charles wrote his father-in-law to gently chide him for bragging to people about what he’d done. His father-in-law’s reply? Essentially “sorry, not sorry.”

Charles wrote a book about his experiences called The Lusitania’s Last Voyage, a riveting and surprisingly modest account.

Color photograph of the outside of a thin black hardbound book. Printed on the cover in red is the text “The Lusitania’s Last Voyage by Charles Lauriat, Jr.” flanked by images of two smokestacks.
The Lusitania’s Last Voyage, by Charles E. Lauriat, Jr.

But I don’t want to give Charles all the attention. The majority of the papers actually belong to his wife Marian (née Bullard). Charles and Marian married on March 20, 1912, and by all accounts, theirs was a very happy and loving union. They had five children together, though their first, Natalie, tragically died as an infant.

Marian’s parents were George P. Bullard and Nina (née Jenks) Bullard, and they’re also represented in the collection, especially Nina. She was a world traveler, wrote detailed diaries and letters about her travels, and even gave speeches to local clubs.  At the outbreak of World War I, Nina was stranded in Europe, and her letters home about the situation were printed in Boston newspapers. Her husband George was a prominent businessman and politician in West Newton, Massachusetts.

Other family members you’ll find in the collection include Charles’s parents; Marian’s sister Clara “Cherry” Bullard, who married Rev. Julian C. Jaynes (the officiant at her parents’ wedding!); cousin Martha F. Metcalf, who taught at schools for the deaf; and Charles and Marian’s children, especially minister Nathaniel and demographer Patience. There’s even an autograph book once belonging to Nina’s younger brother that contains the signatures of Louisa May Alcott, Dickens, Longfellow, Tennyson, and others.

I’d like to mention one person in particular, Rena Struggles. She was a British woman who spent decades working as a housekeeper and child care provider for families in England and the U.S., including the Lauriats. Even when the Lauriat children were grown, Rena corresponded frequently with the family. Her letters during World War II are heartbreaking. She lost her mother and her home in the London Blitz.

The Bullard-Lauriat collection is large; it fills over 32 record cartons. When the boxes came to us, they were full of miscellaneous loose unidentified papers, letters still in envelopes, mountains of acidic newspaper clippings, oversize rolled documents, you name it. I’m very gratified the papers are now arranged, described, and available for any and all interested researchers.