By Dr. Kevin Tallec Marston, CIES Senior Research Fellow and Visiting Lecturer at De Montfort University’s International Centre for Sport History & Culture (UK)

So bountiful are the MHS collections that, undoubtedly on any day, the itinerant researcher can request a document whose date will reveal an anniversary. Today, one such document turns a hundred. Entitled An Historical Sketch of the Oneida Football Club, the eleven-page typescript (plus addenda) was donated on October 18th, 1926, by MHS member, doctor, and former player Robert Means Lawrence. Authored by editor Winthrop Saltonstall Scudder, the document recounts the history of their boyhood team’s salient sporting achievements as the first organized football club in America.
But anniversaries, however factually intriguing, are not in themselves significant. A document attains eminence when its memory meets meaning. The Sketch’s import extends beyond having established a definitive story of (yet another) Boston ‘founding first’. To understand the Sketch’s distinction, we must consider the context from which it emerged as well as its surprising historiographical afterlife as an artifact of a ‘usable past’.
Scudder believed he was writing a definitive a posteriori account. To this end, the memoir cites authorities: football experts Parke H. Davis and Walter Camp. Scudder also built on preserved heritage and club artifacts, some of which found their way into MHS collections. The Sketch builds on a 1906 book (Old Boston Boys and the Games They Played) penned by club member, James D’Wolf Lovett, whose richly annotated copy is among the two editions residing alongside his own papers in the MHS archives. In his Sketch, Scudder recounts how the club members donated their old round ball to the Society for the Preservation of New England Antiquities (Historic New England’s predecessor) as authentic evidence of their claims. Honoring the past also meant looking forward. So younger generations would emulate the ideals of sportsmanship so central to American education’s Muscular Christian ethos, Scudder’s band commemorated the 60th anniversary of their 1863 championship in the form of a bronze tablet for Noble & Greenough school accompanied by Parisian-minted medals endowed as student awards—copies of which were also entrusted to MHS.1 Finally, as Scudder explains in the Sketch, the surviving members commissioned a monument on Boston Common to honor the Oneidas as founders of American football.

Soon began the afterlife of Scudder’s Sketch which saw facsimiles donated widely across Boston’s institutions, six of the eight Ivies, the Library of Congress, and further afield to Oxford University and even the national libraries of Ireland and France. The Oneida story even became an early example of sports marketing. The MHS collections hold a wonderful 1935 lithograph advertisement for the First National Bank of Boston (Bank of America’s eastern predecessor). Produced for the tenth anniversary of the Oneida monument, the print honors the history of American football from its founding on Boston Common.

In a way, Scudder’s Sketch was just the continued preservation of collective social memory. Gifted by Means Lawrence a few years after another Oneida’s erstwhile MHS presidency (Henry Cabot Lodge), the Proceedings of the Society record at least three other former footballers among the MHS membership (Bishop William Lawrence, Frederick Cheever Shattuck, and William Sturgis Bigelow).2 The Sketch fits naturally into the broader antiquarian movement that so colored this era.3 Yet the Oneida story is also a captivating case study in the faultlines between memory and myth, heritage and history; exactly the kind of ‘usable past’ that Van Wyck Brooks—no stranger to the MHS collections—imagined just eight years before the donation of Scudder’s Sketch.4
For if the original 1926 typescript rests intimately with MHS, once the Oneidas had departed, their memory was no longer their own. Memory ceases to be private when it is published, disseminated, engraved, and even partly scanned for perpetuity.5 A dozen years after the first advertisement, a new print honored—and forever altered—the club’s legacy. As cracks began to appear in the Oneida testimony, Scudder’s old club was reappropriated into American soccer history. Because of how the Sketch was produced, preserved and then disseminated, it became a ‘usable past’, such that it shaped the national origin story of not one, but two sports.6
Of course, New England is accustomed to forks in the road. Let us then allow this autumn centenary to remind us of the unexpected fertile verges of history…where two codes (of ‘foot ball’) diverged in a yellow wood…
Kevin Tallec Marston
Dr. Tallec Marston is CIES Senior Research Fellow and Visiting Lecturer at De Montfort University’s International Centre for Sport History & Culture (UK). He has taught for twenty years on the FIFA Master, lectures in history at the University of Neuchatel (Switzerland), and serves as current president of the Society for American Soccer History (SASH).
Co-authored with Mike Cronin of Boston College, Inventing the Boston Game: Football, Soccer and the Origins of a National Myth (UMass Amherst) was the honorable mention for the North American Society for Sport History (NASSH) 2025 Book award.