Adams Family Correspondence, volume 15
The Louisiana Government bill has this day pass’d, yeas 20. Nays
5.— It now goes to the House of Representatives, where we shall see what will be done
with it.— On the final question this day taken I alone spoke against it, and was
answered only by one member— He saw no Constitutional objection—because the clause
authorizing Congress to make needful rules and regulations for the territory, and other
property of the United States was sufficient— The thing could not have been done by a
Constitutional Amendment; because there were five States,
which probably would reject it, from an idea that it carried the weight and […] of the
Union Southward and Westward— And this he presumed was the […] upon which the Amendment
to the Constitution had been proposed by me. (This is the first time I knew they had
such a suspicion—but this accounts for all— They distrust it seems five States on this question— But their suspicion of me is
totally groundless— I sincerely believe that every State would ultimately have agreed to
the Amendment— And 13 of them between this and the next Session.) This circumstance is
however the key to the whole system— I do not think with you that this ground will be
travell’d over again— It will be too late— But the principles to which I appealed have
no weight here as it appears to me, on either side. Of the
federalists only four three voted with me; and they
I believe upon objections to details— One single member of the other side voted also
against the bill—1 Also I presume from
341 an objection to the detail.— I enclose you the
Journals, and the newspaper I promised you2
RC (Adams
Papers); addressed: “Thomas B. Adams Esqr /
Quincy. / Massachusetts”; endorsed: “15 acknd”; notation
by JQA: “Free / John Quincy Adams / S. U.
S.” Some loss of text due to placement of the seal.
On 5 Dec. 1803 JQA accepted appointment to a
committee tasked with drafting a plan of government for Louisiana. The Senate
committee introduced the resulting bill on 10 Jan. 1804, proposing the division of the
territory into two districts. The northern Louisiana District would be placed under
the control of the Indiana territorial government, while the southern district would
be incorporated as Orleans Territory with a government consisting of a governor,
secretary, legislative council, and judiciary. During Senate debate of the measure,
JQA faced the ire both of Democratic-Republicans who wanted to move
ahead without delay and of Federalists who interpreted his actions as seeking
immediate citizenship for Louisiana residents, who they felt would gravitate toward
the opposite party. On 18 Feb. the bill passed the Senate, with JQA
speaking against it. The United States was imposing a government on the people of the
territory without their consent, which, JQA argued, was “the essence of
tyranny” and “destructive of the essential principles of genuine liberty.” The proper
course of action, he declared, was to seek a constitutional amendment approving the
plan and then a ratifying vote by the people of the territory. The five senators who
voted against the bill were JQA, Federalists James Hillhouse of
Connecticut and Simeon Olcott and William Plumer of New Hampshire, and
Democratic-Republican David Stone of North Carolina (Plumer, Memorandum of
Proceedings
, p. 143–146;
Annals of Congress
, 8th Cong., 1st sess., p. 211,
228–229, 233–234, 256;
U.S. Statutes at Large
, 2:283–289;
Biog. Dir.
Cong.
). For House action on the bill and its passage, see
JQA to JA, 20
March, and note 2, below.
Enclosures not found.
ry24 1804
We have this Day quite and old fashiond Snow Storm, after an
unusual pleasent Feb’ry. the Snow is much deeper and more
Drifted than We have had, for Several Winters. the wind Very high at North-East, from
our parlour Windows the Stone walls are not to be Seen. it began yesterday noon to snow,
after Evening, the wind rose, and has continued through the night, and to this time
without abatement. the Winter tho colder than the last, has been generally pleasent.
very little rain. the ground pretty generally coverd with a Slight Snow. the Season
healthy. thus much for the weather. the next Subject is Husbandary. Brisler came the
other day to know if any directions had been left by you respecting the Farm. he
conversed with me, and requested me to write to you. he thinks that Eight cows a pr of
oxen and a Horse together with a dozen head of young Stock, will be as many as can
profitably be kept upon the place. the oxen now upon the place he thinks too old to be
continued upon it, tho 342 they may perform the Spring Work and then be turnd
off, the Young ones he says are not Spirited cattle, & never will be good for Labour
So that he could not advise you to purchase them. Your Father will not object to their
remaining upon the place untill the Labour of the Spring is performd, by which time I
hope you will be returnd here. he will then take them & fat them. 8 cows may be
selected after the 20th of May, Such as will be worth your
purchaseing. as to the quantity of ground to be planted &c I believe you may leave
it to Brislers judgment. the winter has been so mild, that mr Whitney has made great
progress with his House, and I suppose will remove in April or May at furthest. If you have any particular directions to
give, you had better write to Brisler.1
he would like to have a lease drawn, power ought to be lodged with him, to prevent
trespassers, and to punish Theaves. they have so long pillaged wood from your Father
with impunity, that they consider it a kind of Right, and will, & do continue the
Same havock.
My Health about which you so kindly express a concern is better, and I have been abroad several of our pleasent days I can never expect to get rid of the Rheumatism. it will always trouble me. Your Brother has had his Health very well Since his residence here, his Spirits will rise, in proportion to his success in buisness. he has not got under way yet. he cannot be admitted to the Bar untill March; his society has renderd our fire Side much pleasenter this winter. a fish club Saturday dinner has been instituded this winter consisting of Eight families which has contributed to the Sociability of the Neighbourhood. Your Father has joind them, and it has been very pleasing to them.2
You will see by the papers that the Election campaign is opend
early by the Democrats. judge Sullivan & Genll Heath are
agreed upon; and an address somewhat simmilar to Dallas’s is printed & circulated. I
am informd Six thousand coppies are printed. you can judge of its nature, tendency &
bearings when I tell you mr Biddle is the writer.3 I presume mr Shaw will Send you one. the federal
party appear wholy unconcernd, paying very little attention to what is plotting and
executing at the Seat of government, or even in this State— whether they feel conscious
that they are receiving the reward & punishment which their division & base
defection towards their best Friends and Benefactors, has drawn down upon them, or
whether the Love of Mammon so throughly engroses them, that they are become so Luxurious
as to regard little else but property, is 343 not for me to say.
but certainly there is a want of exertion, a want of union, and a cold unconcern which
seem to pervade every breast. So few persons are to be found of fixed and stable
principles, that it is not to be wonderd at, that those Despair of preserving our
constitution from total Ruin & Destruction.
a vessel arrived this week with a Letter for you from the House of Willinks—exchange has been in favour of America and Bills I have understood in great demand.4 have you ever learnt any thing from the House of Bird and Savage Since your absence? they have been declared Bankrupts I hear. I was happy to learn by your Letter to your Brother that You had got your accounts Setled.—5
My Love to mrs Adams & the Children I acknowledge the receipt of a Letter from her, to which I shall reply by the next post.6 We are still very anxious for Mrs Cranch, & are glad to hear from her as often as you can inform us. I expect you will return home very thin in flesh, but the consciousness of holding fast Your integrity, will solace you through Life. I am my Dear son / your affectionate Mother
RC (Adams
Papers); addressed by TBA: “John Q Adams Esqr:”; endorsed: “My Mother 24. Feby: 1804. / 10. March recd: / 14. Do: Ansd:.”
Rev. Peter Whitney Jr. vacated the John Quincy Adams Birthplace
in April 1804 after leasing the property for four years, and JQA,
LCA, and their children began using it as their Quincy residence. John
Briesler Sr. and family had leased the adjacent John Adams Birthplace since 1802, and
Briesler managed the birthplace properties until 1807 (vol. 14:179;
JQA to LCA, 24 April
1804, below; Kirsten Holder, James Bertolini, and Jaime R. Young, Cultural Landscape Report for Adams Birthplaces, Boston,
2014, p. 36, 43, 45–46).
During the congressional recess, JQA also
participated in the weekly gatherings, which TBA described as “a pleasant
society of Country gentleman here, who live in tolerable harmony & good-fellow
ship, and since my return we have formed a Saturday club
& dine on Salt-fish & potatoes and whatever else
we can get, at each other’s houses” (TBA to William Meredith, 26 Feb.,
PHi:Meredith Family Papers;
D/JQA/27, 26 May, APM Reel 30).
The 1804 Massachusetts gubernatorial election pitted the
Federalist incumbents, Gov. Caleb Strong and Lt. Gov. Edward Robbins, against
Democratic-Republican challengers James Sullivan and Maj. Gen. William Heath.
Following a meeting of the Democratic-Republican members of the state legislature in
February, Barnabas Bidwell wrote Address to the People of
Massachusetts, Boston, 1804, Shaw-Shoemaker, No. 5871, in which he criticized Strong for his lack of
support for Jefferson and claimed the governor had ties to the Essex Junto. Bidwell
(1763–1833), Yale 1785, a lawyer who had served in the Mass. senate since 1801, also
attacked JA as an “advocate of the hereditary system” and claimed that
his
Defence of the
Const.
promoted a “monarchic principle.” Bidwell endorsed Sullivan and
Heath, writing that their election would “restore the interrupted harmony between our
government and that of the United States, and regain our forfeited influence and
respectability in the Union” (Bidwell, Address, p. 5, 7,
17, 21–22;
Biog.
Dir. Cong.
). For Alexander James Dallas’ address to Pennsylvania
Democratic-Republicans, see
AA to TBA, 10 Oct. 1802, and note 5, above, and
for the outcome of the Massachusetts election, see
JQA to LCA, 24 April
1804, and note 4, below.
The letter from Wilhem & Jan Willink to JQA has
not been found, but see
JQA to AA, 15 March, below. It was possibly
carried on the brig Seaflower, Capt. Glover, which
arrived in Boston on 12 Feb. after a voyage from Amsterdam of 62 days (Boston Repertory, 14 Feb.).
JQA to TBA, 17 Jan., above.
LCA to AA, 11 Feb., above.