Diary of John Quincy Adams, volume 1
1786-02-11
Eliza spent the day at Mr. White's; went down and drank tea there, with Mr. Thaxter, who was here part of the Evening. Mr. Shaw preaches to-morrow at Boxford, and is to be supplied, by a Mr. Howe,1 who came here this Evening. An extraordinary 402 403Character. He adopted a degree of familiarity, as soon as he came into the house, which, did not in any measure prejudice me in his favour. Indeed by the tenor of his Conversation I am led to Suspect his brain is a little crack'd but the singularity of his behaviour may be owing to the manner in which he has been educated and the Company he has kept. It is said that he carried himself through College, by working at wages as a farmer, at different times, so as to pay his bills, and to avoid being known he went by a feign'd name: this shows, a spirit of Ambition, and fondness for Study, which argue a mind above the common.
Undoubtedly, Dartmouth College
and Associated Schools General Catalogue, 1769–1940, Hanover, N.H., 1940; Eliza Ann
Gibson Stickney, Reminiscences of Brownfield: Short Sketches from
the History of the Town, East Brownfield, Maine, 1901, p. 55–56).
1786-02-12
Mr. Howe, preached us two Sermons from John III. 3. Jesus answered and said unto him,
Verily, verily I say unto thee, Except a man be born again he cannot see the kingdom of God.
The text did not please me at first, and the tenets held forth, were pretty much such as I
should have expected from this beginning. In the morning he said he would have us suppose,
that we all wish'd and desired our own Destruction. In the afternoon we were told, that
without grace, we could not believe, and without believing, we could not be saved; and that
we could not acquire grace of ourselves; nor if we obtained it, was it owing to merit in us.
An Impious System in my opinion. He said that an unregenerate man, supposing even he was
admitted into heaven, could not be happy. This was quite a new Idea, to me. He illustrated
it by a simile saying, a Swine, could never be happy, was he put into a Palace, elegantly
furnish'd. He carried on this elegant simile for ten minutes. Another he made use of was
still more ludicrous. A man could no more obtain grace, by works, than he could walk to get
himself feet. At another time he said Adam's original sin, was imputed to all his Posterity.
I know added he, this point is much contested, but my business is not to prove it here, and
I shall therefore, take it for granted. This is a short way to prove anything, but, although
he maintained a doctrine 404which appeared to me, opposite to common
sense, as well as injurious to the supreme being; yet sometimes he would speak for a quarter
of an hour at a time, with a great degree of energy and Propriety. Some parts were
excellent, but the, whole, was but indifferent at best. Spent
the Evening with Mr. Thaxter. Eliza, was unwell in the afternoon.