Boston Octr. 13th 1754 Dear Sister,

I received yr. kind Epistle1 by Mr. Palmer & should have Answered it by him, but his Sudden Departure after its coming to hand, prevented it.

I am glad to hear of yr. health, & hope yr. Mercantile State of Life will both Profit yr. Purse & Health, I conclude you Recd. by Letters by Cato, & Mr. Prey, tho' you don't mention it; & I'll assure you my neglecting to write so long has not been owing to Unmindfulness, but that the Monday after my Last, we began to move Mrs. Elliots Goods to the long considered of Tenement in Dr. Boylstons Row.2 I was Obliged to take the care of the whole which hindred me till Thursday, & we are scarce settled yet. With Regard to Business, I have at present no prospect of any in perticular & expect this Week to set out wth. Mr. Willard for Lancaster &c.3 You have Doubtless heard of the Arrival & Progress of Mr. White-216field among us. I have heard him twice, admire his Oratory, but condemn his Imprudence, however I'll Endeavour to follow that sagacious Prescription of Dr. Watts, vizt.

"Sieze on Truth where 'ere it grows, Neglect the prickle, but assume the Rose."4

I want to know from you if you have ever look't into the Life of St. Rosalie,5 & if you have, how it affects you. However, let not her sequesterd Virtues wch. consisted in not being known ever instill into yr. Mind any favourable thoughts of a Recluse Life. True Courage & Virtue consists not in flying but in putting to flight.

My Respects to good Freinds there, & be sure to live in all that cheerfulness of Mind wch. Results from the consciousness of an honest heart & in all that freedom of Spirit which having Virtue for its Support defyes Vice in all its Pomp to do its Worst.

Tis so dark I can but guess to scrawl that I still Exist your Loving Brother

ROBERT-TREAT PAINE

NB From Cambridge; they send you many Complements; Mrs. Peggy is really about wedding with a very pretty Gentleman vizt. the Rev, Mr, Prentice of Holliston.6 I herewth. send you, the deed of the Distill-house, which I have got Recorded, and also the Deed of Cato and sundry Papers concerning him.7

RC ; addressed: "To Mrs. Eunice Paine German Town"; endorsed.

1.

Not located.

2.

RTP began boarding at Mrs. Eliot's on Sept. 12. She was Elizabeth (Marshall) Eliot, the widow of Samuel Eliot, bookseller. RTP's diary entry of Oct. 8 reads: "Mrs. Elliot Began to move her Goods to Dr. Boylstones house."

3.

Probably Abel Willard (1731/2–1781), of Lancaster, Mass., brother of Col. Samuel, Abijah, and Levi Willard and a cousin of RTP. He graduated from Harvard in 1752, studied law with Benjamin Prat in Boston, and was admitted to the Worcester Bar in 1755 and as an attorney to the Superior Court in 1762. Willard practiced in Lancaster where he was a selectman and did much local business. Appointed justice of the Peace and Quorum in 1760 he was later proscribed as a loyalist and died in England (Sibley's Harvard Graduates, 13:301–303).

4.

Quotation not located.

5.

The Paine Papers contain a manuscript volume entitled "The Life and Miracles of the Virgina St. Rosalia being the production of the Master, Fryar John of St. Bernard's of the third Order of our Holy Father St. Francis, translated from the Spanish by Robert Treat Paine. 1754."

6.

Joshua Prentiss (1719–1788), the second minister of the First Congregational Church of Hollis-217ton from 1743 until his death, married Margaret Appleton (1720–1768), daughter of Rev. Nathaniel Appleton, on Jan. 9, 1755 (Sibley's Harvard Graduates, 10:312–314).

7.

See RTP to Thomas Paine, Boston, Dec. 10, 1754, printed below.

Boston Octr. 19th 1754 Saturday Dear Eunice,

I Expected this morning to have gone wth. Mr. Willard for Lancaster, but yesterday Sundry Persons arrived from the Cape that I have spoken to you abt. among wch. are Mr. Paine & Mrs. Rachel.1 So I have deferr'd my Journey till next Wednesday, having likewise some other Reasons why I could not go to day. I purpose if it be good Weather to bring Mrs. Rachel down to German Town to see the Glass Works &c, & I expect that Mr. Paine & Capt. Doan will come likewise.1 They are my Obliging Freinds & have a curiosity to see German Town, & I purpose, not to be Burthensome to my freinds there. Tell my Freinds that being an Erratic Planet, they must Expect to see many strange Phenomena, & so the curiosity wch. you express'd in your last Letter will be in some measure allay'd by seeing me Ride, not by the Door, but to the Door.

I Expect to send this by Capt. Franklin, who purposes down to day, but as the wind is foul, he mayn't get there till late. Therefore if you desire to Read this to night you must send for it otherwise 'tis not likely you'll see it till tomorrow. From yr. Loving Brother,

ROBERT-TREAT PAINE

RC ; addressed: "To Miss Eunice Paine German=Town"; endorsed.

1.

Probably Josiah Paine and Capt. Elisha Doane of Wellfleet. RTP notes in his diary for Oct. 21: "Went to German Town in Company wth. Capt. Doane, Mr. Paine &c. and Returned by Eleven oClock. hot day." Mrs. Rachel remains unidentified.

Boston Octr. 30th, 1754 My Lords,

Agreable to the Precedent of the Times I presume to begin my Epistle wth. an hurrangue on precious Self, wch. at present is so confused, so toss'd wth. a thousand passions, that dear as it is, I am almost asham'd to own it. I can scarce turn my Eyes any ways but I have218some new Passion rais'd: when on the one hand I hear Religion exalted above the power of human Nature, & on the other side, see it as much debas'd, my Soul fares hard in the Contrast altho' these extreems follow agreable to the course of Nature. When I see the gaping Croud carried by the Ears, & those who indulged Sloth, leave their Beds by sun rise, I here Admire the Charms of Music. When I behold the favrites of Beauty, dissolving in a flood of Tears, I fancy that Jove attempts their charms in a Shower of Pearls rather than Gold. Innumerable are the other Observations of this sort wch. such an Idle Spectator is induc'd to make, which on Endeavouring to Reconcile, or at least acct. for. The other day my fancy took a flight beyond the reach of my bodily Senses, & during this my Præternatural Elevation, my Imagination presented to me such a Scene, as I shall here take the Liberty to relate, it being strictly Orthodox so to do.

My Soul, Jaded with the bustle of the Town, betook itself to the calm retirement of a rural Retreat; here was no Oratory, but that silent voice of Nature which awakens in every Attentive mind, a never dying & most rational Devotion. Hard by, I saw several buildings, which however of An humble height, yet were vested with such Solemnity, as engaged my earnest Curiosity. The decorum wth. wch. I approach'd, obtained me an admittance by Several Orders of Servants, till I came to a large Room, furnish'd with a variety of Engines & Machines, which I shall Explain as they Occur in the Story. On one Side of the Room I observed two men Standing & giving Orders to various Workmen which together with the peculiar Sagacity of the Visages denoted them to be the Superintenders of the Work, & percieving me an object of their Craft, they concluded I was come to apply to them on the same Acct. The Wonder & Surprize that appeared in my Countenance, was observed by them, which occasioned one of them to address me thus "Inquisitive Mortal, whoever thou Art, urged on by the curiosity of An overheated brain, know, that at the peril of Undergoing a severe process, thou presumest to tread this Sacred Assylum of the Gods, a place so detested & carefully avoided by Most of Mankind, but tho' thy heedless Steps have betray'd thee into Our hands, yet that punishment which we are Obliged to Inflect on thee, shall produce for thee a never Ending Profit. The Gods, added he, in Compassion to the giddy Errors of Mankind, have here set up the Curious & long wanted Brain Refining Laboratory, where the Brains of such Mortals, as we can get into our possession, and find to contain Matter worth219Manufacturing, we purge, cleanse & coin & send forth into the World, fitted to serve the grand purpose of its Creation." He then discanted concerning the Nature & design of the human Brain, observing that they were intended to be a Light to all our Actions, & were the great Labaratory of the Soul, & that by reason of the corrupted constitution of the Brain of some, the Soul was unable to perform those offices for which it was intended. Added he, before we begin the process on your Self, you may indulge your curiosity in seeing the performance on several parcels of Brains which we have here to coin. He then led me into a large Room where were a great Number of Vessels which contain'd every ones Brains Seperately. Some I observed to be very thick & others of a more oyly Constitution. The first process says he, is to Empty these Brains into large Strainers, so as to let the Oyly parts run off, wch. (continues he) is heterogenuous to the Nature of Brains, & of a stinking foetid Smell, however mistaken for them by Most people, & greedily bought up by the vulgar, it being cheap, gives a flairing Light, because 'tis capable to take flame all together, & serves well for your Chimney Corner Wits, & makes good Lamp Black. I observed Some to have little or not Matter in it, the owner of wch. Observed my Instructor, bore the Ball of Reason & Learning for a long Time, Especially when Oppos'd, wch. like a Reverberatory inflammated the Whole of this Oyl, & he shone like Appollo, but when we shall have Reduced him to its proper temperature, we imagine the Light will be but faint. Its observable said he that the true Matter in these Brains, either increases or decreases, in proportion as a greater or Lesser quantity of the Oyl is inflamed at once, wn. a large quantity is inflamed, by its monstruous heat it reduces the real Matter to its own Constitution by degrees Melting it to Oyl, so if but little of the Oyl be inflammated the real Matter which is of an Improving Nature continually Increases, & by degrees sometimes gets the ascendent over the Oyl. I observed that in these Brains as they lay in the Vessells, was mix'd much Blood, and various Sorts of filth, the fluid parts of which run off with the Oyl in straining, the Other remaining closely adheering to the Real Matter.

Having Seperated the Oyl as much as could be done by Straining, the Matter was then put into Baggs, & those put under a large press, which forced out a great Quantity of Oyl, & left the Matter of a hard consistancy, which being melted, cast into large Bodys & Shaved fine, was now fitted to Undergo the last Operation for clearing it of the Oyl, which was by putting it into exceeding strong Cord Baggs & subjecting220 it to a surprising strong Press, they forced out those particles of Oyl that Adhered the most closely to the Matter. This Matter observed my Instructor, is now freed from that erroneous Light, which by its flairing & dazling brightness, has deluded so many from the Straight Course of Reason, to dangerous Swamps & Quagmires, but still here the Blood & filth remains, till which be purged out, this Light must either enkindle up Anger and Persecution &c. or lead into the devious paths of Lust of every sort. Some there are, who have so little Oyl Naturally that you can scarce percieve it, & others who despising it, by vast Labour surpress it, but still this Blood & filth remain, which there are few if any know thoroughly how to purge off; so that altho' they may be free from the false gloss of Reason, yet still their Rational Powers are impeded, with innumerable prejudices & base passions.

'Twould be Endless to describe to you the various Constitutions of Brains that come within our Cognizance, some of which are chiefly Oyl, Blood & other filth, some but little Oyl, yet much Dregs wth. the true matter, some seem to be little else beside Dregs, while some few have but a small mixture of Heterogenous matter. All along my Instructor Observed to me the connextion between the Temperature of the Brain & the Actions of the Owner. I observed a parcel of Brains which Seem'd intirely Oyl & Blood, which he said belong'd to a certain Wit whose chief Talent lay in Scandal, who he reckned would be put into the Ideot House as soon as his Brains were rectify'd. On percieving one parcell very thick of matter, no Oyl but very much Blood, he observed to me that these were the Brains of a Man in a weighty post of Goverment & Instruction, for wch. he was duly qualify'd, saving that the Blood in his Brains had produced a snarling, peevish morose Severity that eclips'd his good Qualifications, & rendered him useless, but that he doubted not, by Separating these Excressions to render him very useful. After various Lectures of this sort he proceeded to refine sundry parcels of Matter that were prepared; wch. he did by Melting them in a large Cauldron, & by a process of Unknown ccelestial Chimistry, he seperated all the heterogeneous parts, & left it a pure Body, transparent as the Œther. Here, wth. an elevated voice, crys he is the pure Matter, as it was first created, the compleat Labaratory for the Soul to work, & the Throne where Reason, unbiass'd by foul Ministers, sits regent. But adds he, in Order to render this pure matter the most useful to human Life, we must reduce it to certain Shapes, & then with the Addition of Experience & Learning, it221will become both a beautiful Ornament & a Never failing Guide to Life. I stood by while he cast some of this Matter into Moulds, & added as he call'd it his polite Learning (wch. to me look'd like a String of Cotton). Observe sd. he the beauty of this form, & the aptitude of its compositione, for while it was an unform'd Body, it was liable to be consum'd to waste, but in its present form, it spends gradual. Without the addition of this Learning, it would be impracticable for it to illuminate the Mind in a regular steady Manner, & without great waste & needless Expence, but by the addition of this Learning, the whole is perform'd at small Expence & with great perspicuity. Altho' 'tis evident the Learning wth. out being surrounded by the Matter, would soon extinguish in a flash, & that much Learning soon distroys little Matter, & that much Matter cant be properly inflammated by little Learning, & therefore as the Learning is design'd only for a vehicle for the Matter, so these ought to be an exact proportion. I observed some of these New form'd Brains were of more curious fashion than others, which however did not augment the Illumination of their real Usefulness in Any Shape. These my Instructor observed, were designed for some Lawyers, Poets, Statesmen & Clergy Men, who for distinction sake insist on their extraordinary Embellishments, wch. however I observed to him very much hindred their Transparency. My Instructor wound up the process, by Observing that this Light is the purest that ever shone in the human Mind, & that when properly assisted with Erudition, it gives the clearest, strongest most inoffensive & most permanent Light existing, however that by Reason of the heterogeneous parts of most kinds of Learning that can be gotten, it often wants Snuffing, yet our Lives guided by this Light will be innocent & just, by this is instilled every Noble Art & beautifying Science, & even Satyr, for nothing more keen & peircing than boiling Matter, yet on the most Delicate Object it leaves no Stain. Here Ended the whole, & the Superintenders, apply'd themselves, to perform this Severe process on My Brains, but finding my head entirely Empty, I was forced to confess that about two Months ago I sold my head Matter for something to fill my Belly. This honest Confession, so moved my kind Instructor, that he presented me with a small quantity of his own choice Head Matter, & bad me find Cotton my Self, wch. I immediately did, but found it to be so heterogeneous, that I wore up severall pair of Snuffers suddenly. In short, I was so worried to make a proper Improvement of this rich present that my fancy left the Inchanting Vision, & returned me to the Regions of Ripe Corrupted Brains, the still222clear Light is all Now Vanish'd, while flame, & Crock, & Spattering Greese, scorch, smutt & defile, by Standers. Much of my time is now spent in guessing the Constitution of the Brain by the Apparent Actions, & when I see a head of Much Matter I wish it in yr. Cauldron.

The above piece is humbly presented, by their Lordships much Obliged most humble and most devoted Servant,

ROBERT TREAT PAINE

RC (Adams Papers, MHS); subscribed: "To the right honbls. Richard Cranch1 & Samuel Quincey2 Esqrs, Lords Superintenders of the Brain Refining Labaratory at Quincey Point"; endorsed.

1.

A draft of this letter in the Paine Papers, dated at Boston, Oct, 15,1754, and addressed to Richard Cranch only, is docketed: ''To RC. Allegorical on the Sperma Ceti Works." Cranch, with others, later formed a firm to manufacture spermaceti candles, a venture that proved unsuccessful (Sibley's Harvard Graduates, 11:371)

2.

Samuel Quincy (1735–1789), the son of Josiah and Hannah (Sturgis) Quincy and a close friend of RTP. He graduated from Harvard in 1754, was admitted to the Massachusetts Bar in 1758, after studying law with Benjamin Prat, and later served as solicitor general, taking part with RTP in the trials of Captain Preston and the British soldiers in 1770. He married Hannah Hill on June 16,1761. A loyalist, he left Boston in 1775 and after a stay in London went to Antigua. He died at sea in 1789 and was buried at Bristol, England (Sibley's Harvard Graduates, 13:478–488).